|This article needs additional citations for verification. (July 2010)|
Coalbed methane (CBM or Coal Bed Methane),1 coalbed gas, or coal mine methane (CMM) is a form of natural gas extracted from coal beds.2 In recent decades it has become an important source of energy in United States, Canada, and other countries. Australia has rich deposits where it is known as coal seam gas (abbreviated "CSG"1).
The term refers to methane adsorbed into the solid matrix of the coal. It is called 'sweet gas' because of its lack of hydrogen sulfide. The presence of this gas is well known from its occurrence in underground coal mining, where it presents a serious safety risk. Coalbed methane is distinct from a typical sandstone or other conventional gas reservoir, as the methane is stored within the coal by a process called adsorption. The methane is in a near-liquid state, lining the inside of pores within the coal (called the matrix). The open fractures in the coal (called the cleats) can also contain free gas or can be saturated with water.citation needed
Unlike much natural gas from conventional reservoirs, coalbed methane contains very little heavier hydrocarbons such as propane or butane, and no natural gas condensate. It often contains up to a few percent carbon dioxide. Some coal seams, such as those in certain areas of the Illawarra Coal Measures in NSW, Australia, contain little methane, with the predominant coal seam gas being carbon dioxide.3
- 1 History
- 2 Reservoir properties
- 3 Extraction
- 4 Environmental impacts
- 5 Coalbed methane producing areas
- 6 References
- 7 External links
Coalbed methane grew out of venting methane from coal seams. Some coal beds have long been known to be "gassy," and as a safety measure, boreholes were drilled into the seams from the surface, and the methane allowed to vent before mining.
Coalbed methane as a natural gas resource received a major push from the US federal government in the late 1970s. Federal price controls were discouraging natural gas drilling by keeping natural gas prices below market levels; at the same time, the government wanted to encourage more gas production. The US Department of Energy funded research into a number of unconventional gas sources, including coalbed methane. Coalbed methane was exempted from federal price controls, and was also given a federal tax credit.
Gas contained in coal bed methane is mainly methane and trace quantities of ethane, nitrogen, carbon dioxide and few other gases. Intrinsic properties of coal as found in nature determine the amount of gas that can be recovered.
Adsorption capacity of coal is defined as the volume of gas adsorbed per unit mass of coal usually expressed in SCF (standard cubic feet, the volume at standard pressure and temperature conditions) gas/ton of coal. The capacity to adsorb depends on the rank and quality of coal. The range is usually between 100 to 800 SCF/ton for most coal seams found in the US. Most of the gas in coal beds is in the adsorbed form. When the reservoir is put into production, water in the fracture spaces is pumped off first. This leads to a reduction of pressure enhancing desorption of gas from the matrix.citation needed
As discussed before, the fracture permeability acts as the major channel for the gas to flow. The higher the permeability, higher is the gas production. For most coal seams found in the US, the permeability lies in the range of 0.1 to 50 milliDarcies. The permeability of fractured reservoirs changes with the stress applied to them. Coal displays a stress-sensitive permeability and this process plays an important role during stimulation and production operations.citation needed
The thickness of the formation may not be directly proportional to the volume of gas produced in some areas.citation needed
For example, it has been observed in the Cherokee Basin in Southeast Kansas that a well with a single zone of 1 to 2 feet (0.3 to 0.6 m) of pay can produce excellent gas rates, whereas an alternative formation with twice the thickness can produce next to nothing. Some coal (and shale) formations may have high gas concentrations regardless of the formation's thickness, probably due to other factors of the area's geology.citation needed
The pressure difference between the well block and the sand face should be as high as possible as is the case with any producing reservoir in general.citation needed
Other affecting parameters include coal density, initial gas phase concentration, critical gas saturation, irreducible water saturation, relative permeability to water and gas at conditions of Sw = 1.0 and Sg = 1-Swirreducible respectively.citation needed
|This section does not cite any references or sources. (May 2012)|
To extract the gas, a steel-encased hole is drilled into the coal seam 100 to 1,500 metres (330 to 4,900 ft) below ground. As the pressure within the coal seam declines due to natural production or the pumping of water from the coalbed, both gas and produced water come to the surface through tubing. Then the gas is sent to a compressor station and into natural gas pipelines. The produced water is either reinjected into isolated formations, released into streams, used for irrigation, or sent to evaporation ponds. The water typically contains dissolved solids such as sodium bicarbonate and chloride but varies depending on the formation geology.citation needed
Coalbed methane wells often produce at lower gas rates than conventional reservoirs, typically peaking at near 300,000 cubic feet (8,500 m3) per day (about 0.100 m³/s), and can have large initial costs. The production profiles of CBM wells are typically characterized by a "negative decline" in which the gas production rate initially increases as the water is pumped off and gas begins to desorb and flow. A dry CBM well is similar to a standard gas well.citation needed
The methane desorption process follows a curve (of gas content vs. reservoir pressure) called a Langmuir isotherm. The isotherm can be analytically described by a maximum gas content (at infinite pressure), and the pressure at which half that gas exists within the coal. These parameters (called the Langmuir volume and Langmuir pressure, respectively) are properties of the coal, and vary widely. A coal in Alabama and a coal in Colorado may have radically different Langmuir parameters, despite otherwise similar coal properties.citation needed
As production occurs from a coal reservoir, the changes in pressure are believed to cause changes in the porosity and permeability of the coal. This is commonly known as matrix shrinkage/swelling. As the gas is desorbed, the pressure exerted by the gas inside the pores decreases, causing them to shrink in size and restricting gas flow through the coal. As the pores shrink, the overall matrix shrinks as well, which may eventually increase the space the gas can travel through (the cleats), increasing gas flow.citation needed
The potential of a particular coalbed as a CBM source depends on the following criteria. Cleat density/intensity: cleats are joints confined within coal sheets. They impart permeability to the coal seam. A high cleat density is required for profitable exploitation of CBM. Also important is the maceral composition: maceral is a microscopic, homogeneous, petrographic entity of a corresponding sedimentary rock. A high vitrinite composition is ideal for CBM extraction, while inertinite hampers the same.citation needed
The rank of coal has also been linked to CBM content: a vitrinite reflectance of 0.8–1.5% has been found to imply higher productivity of the coalbed.citation needed
The gas composition must be considered, because natural gas appliances are designed for gas with a heating value of about 1000 BTU (British thermal units) per cubic foot, or nearly pure methane. If the gas contains more than a few percent non-flammable gases such as nitrogen or carbon dioxide, either these will have to be removed or it will have to be blended with higher-BTU gas to achieve pipeline quality. If the methane composition of the coalbed gas is less than 92%, it may not be commercially marketable.citation needed
As with all carbon based fossil fuels, burning coalbed methane releases carbon dioxide (CO2) into the atmosphere and contributes to global warming. CBM production also involves leaks of fugitive methane into the atmosphere. Methane is rated as having 72 times more effect on global warming than CO2. over 25 years,5 Analysis of life-cycle greenhouse gas emissions of energy sources indicates that generating electricity from CBM, as with conventional natural gas, has less than half the greenhouse gas effect of coal.6
In the United States, methane escaping from coal during mining amounts to 10 percent of total methane emissions. Recovery of coal mine methane in advance of mining is seen as a major opportunity to reduce methane emissions.7
CBM wells are connected by a network of roads, pipelines, and compressor stations. Over time, wells may be spaced more closely in order to extract the remaining methane. Decommissioning wells can cause some problems, as shown when a $75,000 fine was levied when "a blockage leaked cancer-causing chemical benzene" into bores near Kingaroy, Queensland.8
The produced water brought to the surface as a byproduct of gas extraction varies greatly in quality from area to area, but may contain undesirable concentrations of dissolved substances such as salts, naturally present chemicals, heavy metals and radionuclides.9
Tests carried out on soil and water samples from "holding ponds and spill sites" in the Pilliga forest in New South Wales have shown "elevated levels of chloride and barium" and some "were so saline that they could have killed any plants and animals that came into sustained contact with them " and "would kill any animals that depended on it for drinking". There have been reports of kangaroos, frogs, "wallabies, goannas, turtles" dying either from drowning because of inadequate fencing, or from being poisoned by drinking the produced water.10
In 2012 Eastern Star Gas was fined for "discharging polluted water containing high levels of salt into Bohena Creek" in the Pilliga Scrub.11 There were "16 spills or leaks of contaminated water" including "serious spills of saline water into woodland and a creek."12 One of these spills "killed off large numbers of trees."10 The site was sold to Santos and in 2011 the NSW EPA "issued a Formal Warning... for a discharge... that contained elevated levels of ammonia."11 The use of evaporation ponds to store drilling water was banned in NSW in 2011.10 In 2012 a NSW Legislative Council13 inquiry criticised the use of open holding ponds, recommending that "the NSW Government ban the open storage of produced water."1013
Not all coalbed methane produced water is saline or otherwise undesirable. Water from coalbed methane wells in the Powder River Basin of Wyoming, USA, commonly meets federal drinking water standards, and is widely used in the area to water livestock.14 Its use for irrigation is limited by its relatively high sodium adsorption ratio.
Depending on aquifer connectivity, water withdrawal may depress aquifers over a large area and affect groundwater flows.15 In Australia, the CBM industry estimates extraction of 126,000 million litres (3.3×1010 US gallons) to 280,000 million litres (7.4×1010 US gallons) of groundwater per year; while the National Water Commission estimates extraction above 300,000 million litres (7.9×1010 US gallons) a year.9
Commercial recovery of coal seam gas (CSG) began in Australia in 1996. As of 2013, coal seam gas, from Queensland and New South Wales, made up about ten percent of Australia's gas production. Demonstrated reserves were estimated to be 33 trillion cubic feet as of January 2012.16
Complaints have been made that the NSW State Government failed to adequately investigate the Pilliga forest drilling water spills of 2010 and 2011. The case was closed and only reopened after local landholders paid for samples to be taken.17 A NSW Legislative Council13 inquiry found that
It has been revealed that a previously-dismissed concern, namely the pollution of the Pilliga Forest by Eastern Star Gas, was ultimately proven correct. The Committee considers it inexcusable that this pollution went undetected by NSW Government authorities. Given this example of the NSW Government’s failure to adequately police the industry, the Committee is sceptical that all coal seam gas companies are meeting their licence conditions, particularly given the large geographic area in which exploration activity is occurring.—NSW Legislative Council, General Purpose Standing Committee No. 5
In Canada, British Columbia is estimated to have approximately 90 trillion cubic feet (2.5 trillion cubic metres) of coalbed gas. Alberta, to date the only province with commercial coalbed methane wells, is estimated to have approximately 170 trillion cubic feet (4.8 trillion cubic metres) of economically recoverable coalbed methane.18
Coalbed methane is considered a non-renewable resource, although the Alberta Research Council, Alberta Geological Survey and others have argued coalbed methane is a renewable resource because the bacterial action that formed the methane is ongoing.citation needed This is subject to debate since it has also been shown that the dewatering that accompanies CBM production destroys the conditions needed for the bacteria to produce methane19 and the rate of formation of additional methane is undetermined. This debate is currently causing a right of ownership issue in the Canadian province of Alberta, as only non-renewable resources can legally be owned by the province.20
Although gas in place in Britain's coal fields has been estimated to be 2,900 billion cubic meters, it may be that as little as one percent might be economically recoverable. Britain's CBM potential is largely untested. Some methane is extracted by coal mine venting operations, and burned to generate electricity. Assessment by private industry of coalbed methane wells independent of mining began in 2008, when 55 onshore exploration licences were issued, covering 7,000 square kilometers of potential coalbed methane areas. IGas Energy became the first in the UK to commercially extract coalbed methane separate from mine venting; as of 2012, the Igas coalbed methane wells at Doe Green, extracting gas for electrical generation, were the only commercial CBM wells in the UK.21
United States coalbed methane production in 2011 was 1,76 trillion cubic feet (TCF), 7.3 percent of all US dry gas production that year. The 2011 production was down from the peak of 1.97 TCF in 2008.22 Most CBM production came from the Rocky Mountain states of Colorado, Wyoming, and New Mexico.
- "Jargon Buster". BG Group. Retrieved 18 July 2010.
- Coal Gas, www.clarke-energy.com, retrieved 25.11.2011
- "Briefing Note - Lord Mayor - Response to SRACSG - Coal Seam Methane". Retrieved 9 November 2011.
- Geoscience Australia, Coal seam gas, accessed 10 Oct. 2013.
- IPCC Fourth Assessment Report, Table 2.14, Chap. 2, p. 212
- Timothy J. Skone, Life-cycle analysis, 12 May 2011.
- US Environmental Protection Agency, Identifying Opportunities for Methane Recovery at U.S. Coal Mines, EPA 430-K-04-003, Sept. 2008 (Revised Jan. 2009).
- Eliza (26 September 2013). "Two pilot gas projects being decommissioned". ABC Rural website. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 26 September 2013.
- "The coal seam gas rush". ABC News Online. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. April 2012. Retrieved 26 September 2013.
- Coutts, Sharona (26 October 2012). "Pillaging The Pilliga". The Global Mail. Digital Global Mail. Retrieved 26 September 2013.
- "Eastern Star Gas fined for pollution in the Pilliga". Office of Environment and Heritage website. Office of Environment and Heritage. 6 July 2012. Retrieved 26 September 2012.
- Vicky (13 June 2013). "Santos to be prosecuted for Pilliga pollution". Australian Mining. Cirrus Media. Retrieved 26 September 2013.
- "Coal seam gas (Inquiry)". Parliament of New South Wales website. State of New South Wales (NSW Parliament). Retrieved 26 September 2013.
- US EPA, [Evaluation of Impacts to Underground Sources of Drinking Water by Hydraulic Fracturing of Coalbed Methane Reservoirs, The Powder River Basin], June 2004, EPA 816-R-04-003 Attachment 5.
- Montana State University; Frequently Asked Questions; Coal Bed Methane (CBM)
- Geoscience Australia, Coal seam gas fact sheet, accessed 10 Oct. 2013.
- Clifford, Catherine (13 Jun 2013). "Environmentalists say NSW govt ignored Pilliga CSG spills for years". ABC News Online. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. ISBN 9781920788414. Retrieved 26 September 2013.
- John Squarek and Mike Dawson, Coalbed methane expands in Canada, Oil & Gas Journal, 24 July 2006, p.37-40.
- "Renewable Natural Gas? The Discovery of Active Methane Biogenesis in Coalbeds". Green Car Congress. 16 November 2004. Retrieved 2011-12-21.
- "TELUS, news, headlines, stories, breaking, canada, canadian, national". Mytelus.com. Retrieved 2011-12-21.
- DECC, The Unconventional Hydrocarbon Resources of Britain's Onshore Basins - Coalbed Methane, 2012.
- US Energy Information Administration, Coalbed methane production, accessed 9 Oct. 2013.
- U.S. Geological Survey page on CBM
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency page on CBM
- British Columbia Ministry of Energy, Mines and Petroleum Resources guide to coalbed gas
- Kansas Geological Survey guide to Coalbed Methane
- Coalbed Methane Gas
- Coal seam gas: by the numbers Australian Broadcasting Corporation