Governor-General of New Zealand

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Governor-General of New Zealand
Te Kāwana Tianara o Aotearoa
Coat of Arms of New Zealand.svg
Coat of Arms of New Zealand
Jerry Mateparae.jpg
Incumbent
Lieutenant General Sir Jerry Mateparae
GNZM, QSO

since 31 August 2011
Viceroy
Style His Excellency the Right Honourable
Residence Government House, Wellington
Appointer Queen Elizabeth II
on the advice of the Prime Minister of New Zealand.
Term length At Her Majesty's pleasure
Formation 3 May 1841
First holder William Hobson
as Governor of New Zealand
Website gg.govt.nz

The Governor-General of New Zealand (Māori: Te Kāwana Tianara o Aotearoa) is the representative of the monarch of New Zealand (currently Queen Elizabeth II). The governor-general acts as the Queen's vice-regal representative in New Zealand and is viewed by some as the de facto head of state.1234

The Constitution Act 1986 provides that a "Governor-General appointed by the Sovereign is the Sovereign's representative in New Zealand." There is no specific term, but by convention the Governor-General usually serves for approximately five years. The office's full title is: the Governor-General and Commander-in-Chief of the Realm of New Zealand.5

The functions and roles of the governor-general are set out in letters patent issued in 1983 (amended in 2006) and include:5 appointing ministers and judges, dissolving parliament, granting Royal Assent to legislation, issuing writs for elections and bestowing honours. All the governor-general's duties are carried out in the name of the Queen. As of 1 April 2011, the governor-general is paid a salary of NZ$210,309.6

Beyond constitutional functions, the governor-general has an important ceremonial role. He or she travels widely throughout New Zealand to open conferences, attend services and commemorations. When travelling abroad, the governor-general is seen as the representative of New Zealand and of the Queen of New Zealand, and is treated as a head of state in most ways. Under the Niue Constitution Act, the governor-general also represents the Queen in Niue. While Niue is part of the Realm of New Zealand, its status as a self-governing state means that the Governor General's representation of the Queen as head of state in Niue is separate and different from the office of Governor-General of the entire realm.7

The current governor-general is Lieutenant General Sir Jerry Mateparae, who was sworn in on 31 August 2011,8 replacing Sir Anand Satyanand, having been appointed by the Queen of New Zealand on 7 March 2011, on the advice of the Prime Minister.9 The deputy of the governor-general is currently Dame Sian Elias, as Chief Justice of New Zealand.

Administrative support for the governor-general is provided by the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet.

Appointment

Appointment to the Office is made by the Queen (in her capacity as Queen of New Zealand) on the advice of the Prime Minister of New Zealand.10 The Prime Minister's advice has sometimes been the result of a decision by Cabinet,11 although there is no requirement for this. There have been a few instances where the Governor-General was appointed with no consultation of Cabinet; more recently the introduction of MMP has meant the Prime Minister primarily consults with each of the party leaders in Parliament.12 The appointment of Anand Satyanand met with the approval of every leader in the House of Representatives.13 By convention the Leader of the Opposition is also consulted on the appointment, however this too has not always been the case. In 1977 the Leader of the Opposition, Bill Rowling complained he was not consulted on the appointment of Sir Keith Holyoake,2 and openly suggested that he would have appointed Sir Edmund Hillary as Governor-General instead.14 This suggestion was in turn criticised by the Government, as Sir Edmund had backed Labour in 1975 as part of the "Citizens for Rowling" campaign.15

Constitutional convention adopted in 1930 following the Imperial Conference held that year allowed for the appointment of the Governor-General to be made upon the advice and recommendation of the New Zealand Government. However, the right granted by the convention was not exercised directly by a New Zealand Prime Minister until 1967.16

Although non-partisan while in office, there have been a number of appointments of Governors-General to the office that have attracted considerable controversy. In 1977 Sir Keith Holyoake, a former National Party Prime Minister and a serving Minister of State was controversially appointed as Governor-General, and in 1990 Dame Catherine Tizard, a former Labour Mayor of Auckland City and former wife of Labour Deputy Prime Minister Bob Tizard, was appointed to the role. Despite their political backgrounds, neither of these appointments could be said to have discharged their duties in a partisan way.

There has oftencitation needed been speculation that a member of the Royal Family might take up the position. In 2004 former National MP Richard Worth, an avowed monarchist, asked the then Prime Minister Helen Clark whether she had considered nominating the Earl of Wessex to the Queen to be the next Governor-General.17

Swearing-in ceremony

Before the Governor-General enters office, his or her commission of appointment is publicly read in the presence of the Chief Justice of New Zealand (or any other High Court Judge) and the members of the Executive Council. The Governor-General must take the Oath of Allegiance and the oath for the due execution of the office, which the Chief Justice or other High Court Judge administers.

Election proposals

From time to time, there have been proposals to elect the Governor-General. When first drafted by then Governor George Grey, the New Zealand Constitution Act 1852 contained provision for the Governor to be elected by New Zealand's Parliament. This provision was removed from the final enactment, probably because the Colonial Office wanted to keep a check on New Zealand's colonial government. In 1887 Sir George Grey, by then also a former Premier, moved the Election of Governor Bill to make the office of Governor an elective position. The Bill was narrowly defeated 46-48, being opposed by the government of Harry Atkinson.18 In 1889, Grey tried again with another Bill, which if passed would have allowed for a "British subject" to be elected to the office of Governor "precisely as an ordinary parliamentary election in each district."19

In 2006 political commentator Colin James suggested that the Governor-General could be elected20 (or, more correctly, 'nominated' to the Queen) by a 60% majority of votes cast in Parliament. James argued that the New Zealand public should be given the ability to choose the Queen's representative, and that the current system is undemocratic and not transparent. Such a system is not unique: the Governors-General of Papua New Guinea and the Solomon Islands are nominated in such a way. Constitutional law specialist Professor Noel Cox, who is a former chair of Monarchy New Zealand, criticised the proposal, claiming that "[g]iving the Governor-General a new and separate source of democratic legitimacy could result in a separation between Ministers and Governors-General. ...the Governors-General would have their own independent popular mandate, and become potential political rivals of the Ministers".21

In February 2008, the Republican Movement suggested electing the Governor-General as an interim step to a republic, arguing "Electing the Governor-General allows for easier transition to a republic, because the populace is used to electing someone as a ceremonial de facto head of state."22 With the introduction of the Governor-General Act 2010, Green MP Keith Locke suggested Parliament recommend the next Governor-General's appointment to the Queen, with a recommendation endorsed by three-quarters of parliament.23 In its submission to the select committee considering the Bill, the Republican Movement suggested parliament appoint the next Governor-General with a three-quarters majority plus a majority of party leaders in parliament, with a similar dismissal process and a fixed five-year term.24 National MP Nikki Kaye queried whether several one-member parties in parliament could veto the decision, which could give them too much power if an appointment was based on one vote per leader. The Republican Movement responded that the method would ensure appointments were made that most MPs and parties found acceptable.24

Tenure

The Governor-General holds office at the pleasure of the Queen, under clause II of the Letters Patent. It is traditional that an appointed individual act as the Queen's representative for a minimum of five years, but the New Zealand Prime Minister may advise the Queen to extend (or shorten) the Vice-Regal's tenure. For instance, Dame Silvia Cartwright would have been in office for five years on 4 April 2006, but her term as Governor-General was extended by the Queen on the advice of Prime Minister Helen Clark, who deemed that "that the selection and appointment process [should] not coincide with the pre-election period".25

Administrator of the Government

A vacancy will occur on the resignation, death, incapacity or absence from New Zealand territory of the Governor-General. In the absence of the Governor-General the Chief Justice acts as the Administrator of the Government, or simply Administrator in everyday usage.

Prior to the granting of responsible government in 1856, the Colonial Secretary (the colonial equivalent of the Minister of Internal Affairs) acted as Administrator of the Government in absence of the Governor.

Dismissal

The Prime Minister may advise the Queen to recall the Governor-General, and (so long as the Prime Minister has the confidence of the House of Representatives) the Queen is bound by convention to implement the advice of her Prime Minister. As no New Zealand Governor-General has ever been dismissed on the advice of the Prime Minister, it is unclear how quickly the Queen would act on such advice.

Some constitutional lawyers dispute whether the Queen would implement such advice at all, while others argue that the Queen would delay its implementation. Others argue that the Queen would be obliged to follow the Prime Minister's advice, and further that the Queen would be bound to implement the Prime Minister's advice immediately if so advised.26

Critics (usually supporters of a New Zealand republic) describe the ability of the Prime Minister to advise the Queen to recall the Governor-General as a flaw in New Zealand's constitutional make up that gives the Governor-General and the Prime Minister the ability to dismiss one another.27 They argue that this flaw is exacerbated by the reluctance of the monarch or their representatives to become politically involved. Further, they argue that the flaw means the Governor-General is unable to act as the "constitutional backstop" (a term often used to describe the office), or - as was the case with the 1975 Whitlam dismissal in Australia - to resolve a deadlock the Governor-General may choose to dismiss a government despite it having the confidence of the House of Representatives.

Three New Zealand Governors have been recalled from office - William Hobson (who died before he was officially recalled), Captain Robert FitzRoy and Sir George Grey, all before responsible government was granted in 1853.

Functions

The Governor-General's functions can be divided into three areas - constitutional, ceremonial and community.

Constitutional role

The Governor-General is a symbolic and nominal chief executive, acting within the constraints of constitutional convention and precedent. Almost always, the Governor-General exercises the Royal Prerogative on the advice of the Prime Minister and other ministers. The Prime Minister and ministers are, in turn, accountable to the democratically elected House of Representatives, and through it, to the people.

The Constitution Act 1986 provides that "The Governor-General appointed by the Sovereign is the Sovereign's representative in New Zealand." The Governor-General exercises a number of the remaining Royal Prerogatives, and the reserve powers.

In practice, political power is exercised by the Parliament of New Zealand (which is composed of the Governor-General in Parliament, and the House of Representatives), through the Prime Minister and Cabinet. By constitutional convention, the Governor-General exercises his or her powers solely on the advice of the Prime Minister and ministers - the only exception being when the Prime Minister loses the confidence of parliament.

Although the Queen of New Zealand is also Queen of the United Kingdom, as New Zealand is a sovereign nation the British Government cannot advise the Governor-General, or otherwise interfere in New Zealand affairs. The Governor-General is bound by constitutional convention to follow the advice of the Prime Minister in their exercise of constitutional powers, so long as the Prime Minister enjoys the support of the House of Representatives. Even in the appointment of the Prime Minister, the Governor-General rarely exercises any discretion; in accordance with unwritten constitutional conventions, the Governor-General must appoint the individual most likely to maintain the support of the House of Representatives: usually, the leader of the largest party or coalition of parties which has a majority in the House of Representatives.

The Governor-General is the representative of New Zealand's Sovereign, and may (normally with the advice of the Prime Minister) exercise most powers vested in the Crown. If the monarch is present in New Zealand, however, she may exercise such powers personally. Furthermore, some powers (such as the power to appoint the next Governor-General, approve a new Royal Honour etc.) may be exercised by the monarch alone. The Governor-General has custody of the Seal of New Zealand for all official instruments of Her Majesty's Government in New Zealand.28

Every power conferred on the Governor-General by or under any Act is a royal power which is exercisable by the Governor-General on behalf of the Sovereign, and may accordingly be exercised either by the Sovereign in person or by the Governor-General.

—Section 3 of the Constitution Act, 29

The powers conferred on the Governor-General are stated in the Letters Patent 1983.

Executive Council

The Governor-General presides over an Executive Council. The Prime Minister is appointed to this Council and advises as to which parliamentarians shall become ministers and parliamentary secretaries.

The Executive Council's primary function is to issue Orders in Council (regulations), which operate under the authority of "the Governor-General in Council".

Every reference in any Act to the Governor-General in Council or any other like expression includes a reference to the Sovereign acting by and with the advice and consent of the Executive Council.

—Section 3 of the Constitution Act, 29

Parliament and Cabinet

The Governor-General also summons, and dissolves Parliament. Each parliamentary session begins with the Governor-General's summons. The new parliamentary session is marked by the opening of Parliament, during which the Governor-General reads the Speech from the Throne in the Legislative Council Chamber, outlining the Government's legislative agenda. Dissolution ends a parliamentary term (which lasts a maximum of three years), and is followed by general elections for all seats in the House of Representatives. These powers, however, are always exercised on the Prime Minister's advice. The timing of a dissolution is affected by a variety of factors; the Prime Minister normally chooses the most politically opportune moment for his or her party. The Governor-General may theoretically refuse a dissolution, but the circumstances under which such an action would be warranted are unclear. It might be justified if a minority government had served only briefly and another party seemed likely to have better success in holding the confidence of the House.

Every reference in any Act to the Governor-General in Council or any other like expression includes a reference to the Sovereign acting by and with the advice and consent of the Executive Council.

—Section 3 of the Constitution Act,29

People tend to think the office of the Governor-General is of little significance, which is wrong, or that it represents a substantial check on the excesses of executive government, which is also wrong.

Sir Geoffrey Palmer30

Before a bill can become law, the Royal Assent (the monarch's approval) is required. The Governor-General acts on the Monarch's behalf; in theory, he or she may grant the Royal Assent (making the bill law), or withhold the Royal Assent (vetoing the bill). By modern constitutional convention, however, the Royal Assent is always granted, and Bills are never disallowed (see Reserve Powers below).

The Governor-General appoints and dismisses Cabinet ministers and other ministers, but exercises such a function only on the Prime Minister's advice. Thus, in practice, the Prime Minister, and not the Governor-General, exercises complete control over the composition of the Cabinet. The Governor-General may, in theory, unilaterally dismiss a Prime Minister, but convention and precedent bar such an action.

Other viceregal functions

Furthermore, the Governor-General performs some of the functions normally associated with heads of state. He or she makes state visits abroad, hosts foreign heads of state, and receives ambassadors and high commissioners.

Reserve powers

The Queen has the power to appoint and dismiss Ministers and other important office holders, summon and dissolve Parliament, assent to Bills passed by the House of Representatives, and agree to regulations and Orders submitted by Ministers through Executive Council. The Queen delegates most of her powers to her representative, the Governor-General. While the Queen and her representative exercise these powers as a matter of law, as a matter of convention, both the Queen and the Governor-General act on the advice of the democratically elected government, in all but the most exceptional circumstances.

—Former Governor-General Dame Silvia Cartwright, 31

The Governor-General always acts with the advice of the Prime Minister, unless the Prime Minister has lost the confidence of the House of Representatives.32 These are the so-called "reserve powers". These powers include the ability to:

  • Dissolve or prorogue Parliament;
  • Appoint or dismiss Cabinet ministers and the Prime Minister;
  • Refuse a Prime Minister's request for a dissolution;
  • Refuse assent to legislation.

The exercise of the above powers is a matter of continuing debate. Many constitutional commentators believe that the Governor-General (or the Sovereign) does not have the power to refuse Royal Assent to legislation - former law professor and Prime Minister Sir Geoffrey Palmer and Professor Matthew Palmer argue that any refusal of Royal Assent would cause a constitutional crisis.30 However, some constitutional lawyers, such as Professor Philip Joseph, believe the Governor-General does retain the power to refuse Royal Assent to Bills in exceptional circumstances - such as the abolition of democracy.33

As with other Commonwealth realms, the Governor-General's exercise of the royal prerogatives under the reserve powers is non-justiciable;34 that is, they cannot be challenged by judicial review, unlike the actions of other members of the executive (such as the Prime Minister in Fitzgerald v Muldoon.35)

Royal prerogative of mercy

The Governor-General also exercises the royal prerogative of mercy, an ancient right of convicted persons to seek a review of their case where they allege an injustice may have occurred. The prerogative of mercy can be exercised where a person claims to have been wrongly convicted or wrongly sentenced.

The Governor-General acts on the advice of the Minister of Justice. The Governor-General has power to grant a pardon, to refer a person's case back to the court under section 406 of the Crimes Act 1961, and to reduce a person's sentence. If a person's case is referred back to the court, the court will consider the case in a similar way to hearing an appeal. The court then provides advice to the Governor-General as to how to act. Recently, David Bain was granted such an appeal to the Court of Appeal, which in turn was appealed to the Privy Council.

Ceremonial role

I would go as far as to say that we are already a de facto republic, as is Australia. We have, to all intents and purposes the nominal Head of State in our Governor-General

Prime Minister Helen Clark, March 20024

Increasingly, the Governor-General is representing New Zealand abroad and is accorded the same respect and privileges of a head of state. It can be argued that the de facto head of state is the Governor-General while the de jure head of state remains the Queen; historian Gavin McLean has recently described the Governor-General as a "virtual head of state".2

Under the Defence Act 1990 the Governor-General is nominally Commander-in-Chief of the Defence Forces.36 It is not clear whether the commanders of the armed forces could, in reality, turn to the Governor-General if they thought that the orders they were receiving from the Prime Minister and Minister of Defence were illegal or unethical, or whether the Governor-General would be justified in issuing new orders directly.

Until 1939 the Governor-General also represented the British Government, when the diplomatic functions were transferred to a High Commissioner. This was 13 years after the Balfour Declaration and after the functions were separated in the other Dominions. This was due to the New Zealand belief that such a thing would promote separatism within the British Empire.

Community role

The Governor-General provides leadership in the community. Governors-General are always the patrons of many charitable, service, sporting and cultural organisations. The present Governor-General is patron to nearly 200 organisations. The sponsorship or patronage of the Governor-General signals that an organisation is worthy of wide support. Many of the Governor-General's community functions also have a ceremonial dimension, such as attendance at the official openings of buildings, addresses to open conferences, or launching special events and appeals.

The Governor-General spends a large share of his or her working time attending state banquets and functions, making and hosting state visits, meeting ceremonial groups, and awarding medals, decorations, and prizes.

Starting from New Year's Day 2009, the Governor-General issues a New Year's Message to bring to attention to issues New Zealanders might consider as they look to the future.37

Salary and privileges

Government House, Wellington, the primary residence of the Governor-General.
The official vehicle of Government House in 2010, a Jaguar XJ8. During official travel it is the only vehicle in the country not required to use standard number plates.38

Cost

The New Zealand Government pays for the costs associated with the Governor-General. Monarchy New Zealand states "[t]his figure is about one dollar per person per year", about $4.3 million per annum.39 An analysis by the Republican Movement of Aotearoa New Zealand of the 2010 Budget shows the office of Governor-General costs New Zealand taxpayers about $7.6 million in ongoing costs and $11 million for Government House upgrades, a total of $18.6 million.404142 These figures are disputed by Monarchy New Zealand, who claim the Republican Movement "arbitrarily inflated the cost of the Governor-General".43

Salary

As of 1 April 2011, the annual salary is NZ$210,309,644 which is subject to income tax from 2010.45 Until the end of Sir Anand Satyanand's term, the salary of Governor-General was regulated by the Civil List Act 1979. From the start of Sir Jerry Mateperae's term, the Governor-General Act 2010 applies.

Residence

The Governor-General's main residence is Government House, Wellington, and there is a small secondary northern residence, Government House, Auckland. The houses are managed by the Official Secretary to the Governor-General. Government House closed in October 2008 for a major $44 million conservation and rebuilding project and was reopened in March 2011.46

Precedence and titles

In the order of precedence, the Governor-General outranks all individuals except the head of state. (The Queen herself is not listed in the order of precedence.)

The Governor-General and their spouse are styled "His/Her Excellency" during the term in office and are entitled to the style "The Right Honourable" for life upon assuming the office.47 From 2006, former living Governors-General were entitled to use the style "the Honourable", if they did not already hold the title or the higher appointment of Privy Counsellor.31

The Governor-General uses the titles of Chancellor and Principal Knight or Dame Grand Companion of The New Zealand Order of Merit48 and Principal Companion of the Queen's Service Order.49

Governor-General's flag

The Governor-General's flag is a dark blue flag with the Shield of the New Zealand Coat of Arms surmounted by a Royal Crown in the centre. In heraldic terms the official description is: "A flag of a blue field thereon the Arms of New Zealand ensigned by the Royal Crown all proper". It takes precedence over all other flags, except the head of state's flag. It may be flown from a vehicle in which the Governor-General is travelling, or from a building in which the Governor-General is present or is residing. On state visits abroad, however, the Governor-General typically uses the national flag, which is a more recognisable New Zealand symbol.

History

Colony

William Hobson, first Governor of New Zealand.

From 1832 James Busby was assigned the post of British Resident in New Zealand. Under his direction the signing of the Declaration of Independence of New Zealand at Waitangi established the post of Governor in New Zealand. Captain William Hobson was first appointed Lieutenant-Governor of New Zealand by Letters Patent on 24 November 1840 (having previously been the British Consul to New Zealand), when New Zealand was part of the colony of New South Wales. While Hobson is usually considered the first Governor of New Zealand, Sir George Gipps was the first governor over New Zealand, albeit only in his capacity as Governor of New South Wales, until New Zealand was established as a separate colony on 3 May 1841. Hobson continued in office until his death on 10 September 1842. In Hobson's place the Colonial Office appointed Captain Robert FitzRoy. FitzRoy struggled to keep order between Māori and settlers keen to buy their land, with very limited financial and military resources at his disposal. His conflicts with the New Zealand Company settlements over land deals lead to his recall in 1845. FitzRoy's replacement, Sir George Grey, is considered by some historians, such as Michael King,50 to be the most important and influential Governor of New Zealand. Grey was the last Governor of New Zealand to act without reference to parliament. During his first term (1845–1852), Grey petitioned the Parliament of the United Kingdom to largely suspend the complex New Zealand Constitution Act 1846 (Grey briefly took the title Governor-in-Chief under the Act but this was eventually reverted to Governor), drafting his own constitution bill, which became the New Zealand Constitution Act 1852. Grey's first term ended before responsible government was implemented.

That task was left to the Administrator of the Government, Robert Wynyard who opened the 1st New Zealand Parliament on 24 May 1854.2 Wynyard was quickly confronted by the demands of the new parliament that the parliament be able to appoint its own ministers, instead of the governor. The parliament passed a resolution to that effect on 2 June. Wynyard and the Executive Council of New Zealand refused to allow this, stating that the Colonial Office made no mention of responsible government in its dispatches. Wynyard then offered to add some elected members of parliament to the Executive Council, which he did - a compromise that worked for a few weeks, until on 1 August 1854, Parliament again demanded complete power to appoint ministers. Wynyard refused, and prorogued parliament for two weeks. Then on 31 August he appointed more elected members to the Executive Council, but when parliament met again on 8 August 1855, it moved a motion of no confidence in the members. Fortunately for Wynyard the next Governor, Sir Thomas Gore Browne, arrived on 6 September 1855. Gore Browne's tenure saw the introduction of responsible government, which greatly reduced the powers of the Governor.2 In the following years, Gore Browne and Premier Edward Stafford clashed over whether the Governor (and hence the imperial government) had control over Māori affairs, a key issue at the time. Stafford began the practice of Cabinet meeting independently of the Executive Council, further reducing the influence of the Governor. Sir George Grey returned to New Zealand in 1861 for a second term. Grey struggled to meet the competing demands of the Colonial and British governments. The New Zealand Wars had brought many British troops to New Zealand, and fearing further fighting Grey, with the support of Edward Stafford, evaded Colonial Office instructions to finalise their return to Britain. In the end the Colonial Office recalled Grey in February 1868.51

Governor

After Grey, successive Governors of New Zealand were derived from the British aristocracy and played a much less active role in government.2 In only a few instances did the Governor refuse the advice of the Premier - ironically mainly during the tenure of Sir George Grey as Premier of New Zealand from 1877 to 1879.2 One famous instance of the use of the Governor's powers came during the term of Sir Arthur Gordon. Sir Arthur had left New Zealand on 13 September 1881 for a visit to the Pacific Islands. In his absence, the Premier John Hall advised the Chief Justice James Prendergast acting as the Administrator of the Government (Prendergast was well known for his views on Maori from his decision in the case Wi Parata v the Bishop of Wellington), to order the invasion of the Maori pacifist Te Whiti o Rongomai's village at Parihaka, something the Governor had indicated he was opposed to.2

Governor-General

In 1907 Sir Joseph Ward's Liberal government passed a resolution to create New Zealand as the Dominion of New Zealand. This led to new letters patent being issued in 1917, which greatly curtailed the powers of the Governor.16 To reflect these changes, the office was renamed Governor-General (equivalent to Governors-General of other Commonwealth countries), with the Earl of Liverpool, the serving Governor, being the first Governor-General.

In 1926, following the King-Byng affair in Canada, an Imperial Conference approved the Balfour declaration, which defined a British Commonwealth as a freely associated grouping known as the Commonwealth of Nations. The declaration was ratified by the Parliament of the United Kingdom with the Statute of Westminster 1931. The effect of the Declaration was to elevate the Governor-General from a representative of the British government to a regal position with all the theoretical constitutional powers of the Sovereign. New Zealand did not ratify the statute until after the Second World War however, with the Statute of Westminster Adoption Act 1947 being passed on 25 November 1947.

Despite adopting the statute later than most other Commonwealth realms, the functions of the Governor-General in representing the British government were gradually reduced prior to the statute passing. In 1939 Britain appointed its own High Commissioner to New Zealand, Government House ceased to be the official communications channel with Britain in 1941.2 In 1945 Labour Prime Minister Peter Fraser suggested that Sir Bernard Freyberg, the British-born commander of New Zealand's armed forces be appointed Governor-General. Until 1967 the precedent was that Governors-General were nominated by the Foreign and Commonwealth Office in consultation with the New Zealand Prime Minister, who then recommended appointments to the Sovereign.

New Zealand Governors-General

In 1967 the first New Zealand-born Governor-General, Sir Arthur Porritt (later Lord Porritt), was appointed to the office, on the advice of Sir Keith Holyoake. Porritt's appointment was followed by Sir Denis Blundell in 1972, who was the first fully New Zealand-resident Governor-General. The appointment of his successor, former Prime Minister Sir Keith Holyoake proved highly controversial, although Holyoake's tenure itself was uncontroversial. In 1983, letters patent were issued once again, further reducing the powers of the office.16 Following the 1984 constitutional crisis, the 1852 Constitution Act was replaced by the Constitution Act 1986 and the Governor-General's powers further limited - for example, section 16 of the 1986 Act significantly narrowed section 56 of the 1852 Act so that the Governor-General has much less discretion to refuse Royal Assent to Bills of parliament.2952

De facto head of state

Increasingly, the Governor-General is regarded as a de facto head of state. Political commentator Colin James has expressed this view,3 along with historian Gavin McLean2 and former Prime Minister Helen Clark.4 The Governor-General has been performing more and more of the functions of a head of state, such as representing New Zealand overseas (a duty Governors-General have carried out since Sir Denis Blundell was in office).2 For example, at the 2007 commemorations of the Battle of Passchendaele, the Governor-General Anand Satyanand represented New Zealand53 on behalf of the Queen, while the Queen represented the United Kingdom.54dead link

Reform of the office is usually only mentioned in the context of a New Zealand republic. Helen Clark, when defending Dame Silvia Cartwright following a political controversy over prison sentences, stated "[o]ne of the challenges for us is we clearly are no longer a dominion of Britain where the Governor-General is exactly like the Queen. I think we need to consider how the role of governor-general might evolve further. As you know, my view is that one day there will be a president fulfilling the kind of role the governor-general does."55 Others, such as Professor Noel Cox have argued that the Governor-General's role needs to be updated, rather than reforming the office.21 Some constitutional academics expressed concern that the process of electoral reform could result in the Governor-General having greater political influence.26 In 1993, the then Governor-General Dame Catherine Tizard caused controversy by suggesting that under the proposed Mixed Member Proportional (MMP) electoral system, the Governor-General may have to use their reserve powers more often.2 Following the adoption of MMP at a referendum later in 1993, Prime Minister Jim Bolger suggested at the opening of parliament in 1994 that one reason New Zealand might move to a republic was that the Governor-General would have more influence under the new electoral system.56

In December 2009 a review of the Civil List Act 1979 by the Law Commission recommended that part 1 of the Act be repealed, and replaced with a new Governor-General Bill to reflect the nature of the modern office of Governor-General. The most significant change would be that the Governor-General was no longer exempt from paying income tax on their salary. The changes proposed in the report would take effect for the appointment and term of the next Governor-General.57 The Bill was introduced into Parliament on 28 June 201058 and was granted Royal Assent on 22 November 2010.59

The Bill passed its first reading unanimously,23 and the Republican Movement launched 'New Zealand's Next Governor-General' to create a "citizens process" for selecting the next Governor-General.60

See also

References

Citations

  1. ^ McLean 2006, p. 17.
  2. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l Gavin McLean (October 2006), The Governors, New Zealand Governors and Governors-General, Otago University Press, ISBN 978-1-877372-25-4 
  3. ^ a b Colin James (22 August 2006). "The huge challenge ahead of the Maori Queen's successor". New Zealand Herald. 
  4. ^ a b c "Republic 'inevitable' - Clark". The Evening Post. 4 March 2002. 
  5. ^ a b Elizabeth II (28 October 1983), Letters Patent Constituting the Office of Governor-General of New Zealand, New Zealand Government Printer 
  6. ^ a b "Civil List Determination 2011 (SR 2011/208)". New Zealand Legislation: Regulations. 15 June 2011. 
  7. ^ https://www.victoria.ac.nz/law/research/publications/vuwlr/prev-issues/pdf/vol-34-2003/issue-3/townend.pdf
  8. ^ Bennett, Adam (31 August 2011). "New governor-general sworn in". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 1 October 2011. 
  9. ^ "Appointment of new Governor General o fNewZealant". The British Monarchy. 7 March 2011. Retrieved 2011-03-07. 
  10. ^ "Role of the Governor-General". Government House. Retrieved 29 January 2010. 
  11. ^ Working with David: inside the Lange cabinet by Michael Bassett. Auckland, New Zealand: Hodder Moa. 2008. ISBN 978-1-86971-094-1. 
  12. ^ Dennis Welch (1 August 2009). Helen Clark: A Political Life. New Zealand: Penguin NZ. ISBN 978-0-14-320241-7. 
  13. ^ "Broad support for new Governor Gen". TVNZ. 6 April 2006. 
  14. ^ Rowling: The man and the myth by John Henderson, Australia New Zealand Press, 1980.
  15. ^ Ross Doughty (1977). The Holyoake years. Feilding. 
  16. ^ a b c Phillip A Joseph (2001). Constitutional and Administrative Law in New Zealand. Wellington: Brookers. 
  17. ^ "Sir Geoffrey popular choice for governor-general -- poll". New Zealand Herald. 26 November 2004. 
  18. ^ Keith Sinclair (1986), A Destiny Apart - New Zealand's Search for National Identity, Unwin Paperbacks 
  19. ^ New Bills XLIX (4594). The Timaru Herald. 18 July 1889. p. 3. Retrieved 2011-02-08. 
  20. ^ Colin James (17 January 2006). "Election: the democratic way to select our Governor-General". The New Zealand Herald. 
  21. ^ a b Noel Cox (8 February 2006). "Governor-General role needs an update". The New Zealand Herald. Archived from the original on 2009-10-22. 
  22. ^ "Republic newsletter". February 2008. Retrieved 2008-05-05. 
  23. ^ a b Andrea Vance. "New bill doubles governor-general's severance". The Dominion Post. 
  24. ^ a b NZPA (18 August 2010). "Call for 75% support from Parliament for new GGs". Otago Daily Times. Retrieved 18 August 2010. 
  25. ^ New Zealand Government (31 January 2005). "Governor General's term extended". Scoop.co.nz. 
  26. ^ a b Andrew Stockley (1996). "Becoming a republic? Issues of Law". In Luke Trainor. Republicanism in New Zealand. Dunmore Press. 
  27. ^ "Republic: Newsletter of the Republican Movement of Aotearoa New Zealand: Putting the case" (PDF). Retrieved 2007-03-31. 
  28. ^ "Seal of New Zealand Act 1977". 
  29. ^ a b c d "Constitution Act 1986". 
  30. ^ a b Sir Geoffrey Palmer and Matthew Palmer (2004). Bridled Power: New Zealand's Constitution and Government (Fourth ed.). Oxford University Press. ISBN 0-19-558463-5. 
  31. ^ a b Dame Silvia Cartwright (23 June 2006). "Modern aspects of the role of the Governor‑General of New Zealand". Government House. Retrieved 2007-08-13. 
  32. ^ Sir Kenneth Keith (2008). "On the Constitution of New Zealand: An Introduction to the Foundations of the Current Form of Government". Retrieved 12 September 2011. 
  33. ^ Philip Joseph (2002). Constitutional and Administrative Law in New Zealand (Second ed.). Brookers. ISBN 978-0-86472-399-4. 
  34. ^ "The Executive and the Whitlam Dismissal". Northern Territory University. Retrieved 2009-05-22. 
  35. ^ Fitzgerald v Muldoon 2 NZLR 615 (1976)
  36. ^ "Review of Defence Force Standards of Behaviour". State Services Commission. 16 July 2002. Retrieved 2007-07-13. 
  37. ^ "Governor-General issues New Year message for 2009". Government House. 2 January 2009. Retrieved 2009-01-02. 
  38. ^ "The Governor-General's Rolls-Royce". New Zealand Ministry for Culture and Heritage. Retrieved 21 September 2010. 
  39. ^ "Cost of the Monarchy". Monarchy New Zealand. 2009. Retrieved 2010-10-02. 
  40. ^ "Vote Prime Minister and Cabinet". New Zealand Treasury. May 2010. pp. 269–270. Retrieved 2010-10-02. 
  41. ^ "Defending the monarchy - the cost". Republican Movement of Aotearoa New Zealand. 2010. Retrieved 2010-09-26. 
  42. ^ Republican Movement (20 May 2010). "Governor-General more expensive". Scoop.co.nz. 
  43. ^ "Monarchy New Zealand Calls for the Resignation of Republican Chair". 28 October 2010. Retrieved 15 November 2010. 
  44. ^ "'Taxing' governor-general's salary proposed". Stuff.co.nz. 18 December 2009. 
  45. ^ "Civil List Act 1979". Knowledge Basket. Retrieved 2007-08-08. 
  46. ^ Michelle Duff (28 March 2011). "Government Houses $44m facelift". Retrieved 18 April 2011. 
  47. ^ Rt. Hon. Helen Clark (17 July 2006). "Changes to rules around use of title". The Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet of New Zealand. Retrieved 2007-08-21. 
  48. ^ Statutes of the New Zealand Order of Merit 1996, reg 5
  49. ^ Statutes of the Queen's Service Order 1975, reg 4
  50. ^ Michael King (2003). The Penguin History of New Zealand. Penguin. 
  51. ^ Keith Sinclair (7 April 2006). "Dictionary of New Zealand Biography George Grey 1812 - 1898". Retrieved 2007-07-03. 
  52. ^ Sir Geoffrey and Matthew Palmer (2001). Bridled Power - New Zealand's Constitution and Government. Oxford University Press. 
  53. ^ "Governor-General visits Belgium for Passchendaele Commemoration". Government House. 6 July 2007. 
  54. ^ Associated Press (11 July 2007). "Queen Elizabeth II, Belgian royals pay tribute to allied soldiers of Passchendaele battle". International Herald Tribune. 
  55. ^ NZPA (15 August 2002). "Clark foresees president role". New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 2007-07-23. 
  56. ^ Jim Bolger (March 1994). Address-In-Reply debate, state opening of Parliament. 
  57. ^ "Review of the Civil List Act 1979: Law Comm Report". New Zealand Law Commission. 17 December 2009. Retrieved 2009-12-18. 
  58. ^ "Parliament of New Zealand - Order Paper". Parliament of New Zealand. 30 June 2010. 
  59. ^ "Governor-General Act 2010". 
  60. ^ "Media release - Governor-General Bill good start at reform". Scoop.co.nz. 20 July 2010. Retrieved 21 July 2010. 

Bibliography

External links








Creative Commons License