History of European research universities

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Logotype of the University of Bologna

European research universities date from the founding of the University of Bologna in 1088 or the University of Paris (c. 1160–70). In the 19th and 20th centuries, European universities concentrated upon science and research, their structures and philosophies having shaped the contemporary university. The original medieval universities arose from the Roman Catholic Church schools that became “the university." Their purposes included training professionals, scientific investigation, improving society, and teaching critical thinking and research. External influences, such as Renaissance humanism (c. mid-14th century), the Age of Enlightenment (18th century), the Protestant Reformation (1517), political revolution, and the discovery of the New World (1492) added human rights and international law to the university curricula.

By the 18th century, universities published academic journals; by the 19th century, the German and the French university models were established. The German university — the Humboldtian model — established by Wilhelm von Humboldt was based upon Friedrich Schleiermacher’s liberal ideas about the importance of freedom, seminars, and laboratories, which, like the French university model, involved strict discipline and control of every aspect of the university. In the 19th and 20th centuries, the universities concentrated upon science, but were not open to the general populace until after 1914. Moreover, until the 19th century’s end, religion exerted a significant, limiting influence upon academic curricula and research, by when the German university model had become the world standard. Elsewhere, the British also had established universities world-wide, thus making higher education available to the world’s populaces.

Friedrich Daniel Ernst Schleiermacher

The first European universities

Historically, the University of Bologna, founded in 1088, is considered the “mother of European universities.” However, this claim was made as symbolic of Italian national unity, leading some to question the legitimacy of Bologna's claim to be the first university proper.1 If the term "university" requires that a single corporate body be made up of students and professors of different disciplines, rather than that a corporate body simply exists, the University of Paris, founded in 1208, can be considered the first university2

Representation of a university class, 1350s.

The rediscovery of ancient Græco–Roman knowledge (e.g. Aristotle’s works and Roman law), led to the development of universitates (student guilds), and thus the establishment of the university in the contemporary sense.3 In turn, the traditional medieval universities — evolved from Catholic and Protestant church schools — then established specialized academic structures for properly educating greater numbers of students as professionals. Prof. Walter Rüegg, editor of A History of the University in Europe, reports that universities then only trained students to become clerics, lawyers, civil servants, and physicians. 4 Yet rediscovery of Classical-era knowledge transformed the university from the practical arts to developing “knowledge for the sake of knowledge”, which, by the 16th century, was considered integral to the civil community’s practical requirements.5 Hence, academic research was effected in furtherance of scientific investigation,6 because science had become essential to university curricula via “openness to novelty” in the search for the means to control nature to benefit civil society.7

The structure and spread of early European universities

The European University proliferated in part because groups decided to secede from the original universities to promote their own ideals; the University of Paris fostered many universities in Northern Europe, while the University of Bologna fostered many in the South. 8 Some leaders also created universities in order to use them to increase their political power and popularity. For example, Frederick II, Holy Roman Emperor founded the University of Naples in 1224 to train lawyers and administrators who could rival the University of Bologna's influence, which served the hostile Lombard League. 9

The structure of these early classes involved a master reading from texts and commenting on the readings, as well as students learning by teaching other students. Masters also offered disputed questions to their classes for discussion.10 Moving into the 18th century, professors became less focused on simply training university teachers and more focused on “forming the minds of the elite” of a larger society.11

Philosophic and external influences

By the 16th century, the humanist ideas of the Renaissance (14th–16th century) were slowly accepted; France had propagated them first to Germany, then to England, during the Protestant Reformation (1517).12 In that intellectual humanist mode, university education began including preparing the student for a civilized life — of culture and civility — and concern for society’s public affairs.13 To achieve that, the curriculum comprised the liberal arts Trivium (grammar, rhetoric, logic), and the Quadrivium (arithmetic, geometry, astronomy, music) meant to prepare students for further specialized education in either theology, the law, or medicine. 14 In 1492, the socio-political consequences of the discovery of the New World expanded European university curricula, as human rights and international law became contemporarily relevant matters.15 The Spanish enslavement of the native (aboriginal) populaces they conquered in the “New World” of the Americas eventually raised ethico-moral questions in Europe about the human rights of the American aboriginals — questions of cultural tolerance evinced by Renaissance humanism, the Bible, and mediæval theories of natural law.16 In analogy to the ancient world’s works, Rüegg relates the “New World” idea to the idea of “new knowledge”. In the mid-16th century, scholarly and scientific journals made it feasible to “spread innovations among the learned”; by the 18th century, universities published their own research journals.17 In the 18th century, the Age of Enlightenment also encouraged education’s transition, from the “preservation and transmission of accepted knowledge” to the “discovery and advancement of new knowledge”; the newer universities effected that change more quickly, and adapted Enlightenment ideas about the harmfulness of monarchic Absolutism more readily than did the older universities.18

European university models in the 19th and 20th centuries

Modern universities

BME, The oldest University of Technology, founded in Hungary in 1782
Wilhelm von Humboldt

Moving into the 19th century, the objective of universities evolved from teaching the “regurgitation of knowledge” to “encourag[ing] productive thinking.”19 Two new university models, the German and the post-Revolutionary French Grandes écoles, arose and made an impact on established models such as the Russian and Britain - especially the newer foundations of University College London and King's College London. Such free thinking and experimentation had notably already begun in Britain's oldest universities beginning in the seventeenth century at Oxford with the fathers of British scientific methodology Robert Hooke and Robert Boyle, and at Cambridge where Isaac Newton was Lucasian Professor of Mathematics & Physics. The dawn of the Age of Enlightenment and decline of classical medieval Scholasticism across Europe, as in Russia, made fertile ground for the German organizational approach as a consequence. The German model, conceived by Wilhelm von Humboldt, was also known as the Humboldtian model. In 1810, Humboldt convinced the King of Prussia to build a university in Berlin based on Friedrich Schleiermacher’s liberal ideas; the goal was to demonstrate the process of the discovery of knowledge and to teach students to “take account of fundamental laws of science in all their thinking.” Thus, seminars and laboratories started to evolve. 20 Humboldt envisioned the university education as a student-centered activity of research:

Just as primary instruction makes the teacher possible, so he renders himself dispensable through schooling at the secondary level. The university teacher is thus no longer a teacher and the student is no longer a pupil. Instead the student conducts research on his own behalf and the professor supervises his research and supports him in it.21

The main Entrance to Old College at Aberystwyth University.

Freedom was an important concept in the German university model, and the system of professors was based on competition and freedom: although professors served as state functionaries, they had the freedom to choose between several states, and their identity and prestige arose from the specialization of scientific disciplines.22

The French University model lacked the freedom of the German model, consisting of severe discipline and control over the curriculum, awarding of degrees, conformity of views, and personal habits (for example, there was a ban on beards in 1852).23 French university professors trained at the École Normale Supérieure, and much of their prestige depended on their schools’ reputations.24 By 1866, though, the German model had begun to influence the strict French model.25

The German university model was also used in Russian universities, which hired lecturers trained in Germany and which dedicated themselves to science. At the same time, Russian universities were meant to train the bureaucracy in the same way as the French grandes écoles. Throughout the 19th and 20th centuries, Russian universities underwent much variation in their degrees of strictness and control.26

British universities of this period adopted some approaches familiar to the German universities, but as they already enjoyed substantial freedoms and autonomy the changes there had begun with the Age of Enlightenment, the same influences that inspired Humboldt. The Universities of Oxford and Cambridge emphasized the importance of research, arguably more authentically implementing Humboldt’s idea of a university than even German universities, which were subject to state authority.27

Overall, science became the focus of universities in the 19th and 20th centuries. Students could conduct research in seminars or laboratories and began to produce doctoral theses with more scientific content.28 According to Humboldt, the mission of the University of Berlin was to pursue scientific knowledge.29 The German university system fostered professional, bureaucratically regulated scientific research performed in well-equipped laboratories, instead of the kind of research done by private and individual scholars in Great Britain and France.30 In fact, Rüegg asserts that the German system is responsible for the development of the modern research university because it focused on the idea of “freedom of scientific research, teaching and study.”31

Professors and Students

Schleiermacher posits that professors, had to “reproduce [their] own realization[s]” so that students could observe the “act of creation” of knowledge.32 That they serve as models of how to “intelligently produce knowledge”.33 Professorship was awarded to distinguished scholars, and was rescindable only if guilty of a serious crime.34 From the perspective of James McCain, president emeritus of Kansas State University, professors in 20th-century Europe were more prestigious and well respected than university professors in the US, for having much academic freedom, whilst keeping to formal relationships with the students. 35 Moreover, the professors’ professional role expanded from lecturing to investigating, thus research became “an integral part of the professor’s task”.36

The London University, by Thomas Hosmer Shepherd (1827–28), now is integral to University College London, a constituent of the University of London.

Popular access to higher education slowly began after 1914,37 yet the principal remaining obstacle was its expense. For most of the 19th century, the UK continued affording a university education only to aristocrats, and not until the early 20th century, featuring new universities, such as the University of London, was higher education available to the mass populace.38 Moreover, it was not until the mid-19th century that universities admitted women students, who confronted great difficulties, such as having no civil rights and societal-institutional sexism doubting their intellectual capacities and their right to participate in a university education.39 In the event, the entrance of common students to the universities challenged the ideology of the German model, because their varied middle- and working-class backgrounds, hence different expectations, resulted in a less concretely Humboldtian university.40

In the 19th and 20th centuries, European university students were mostly responsible for their educations; they selected courses of study, professors did not register attendance, and only gave examinations at course’s end. 41 42 Rüegg suggests that student propensity to developing student movements, based upon contemporary politics, parallels their attitudes of intellectual freedom and social responsibility.43

Progressive educational and political philosophies changed religion’s role in the education imparted. During the 18th century, most universities were strongly connected to either a Catholic or a Protestant church, thus the professors’ and the students’ religion determined employment and matriculation.44 In the 19th century, religion was deleted from the “compulsory curriculum”; in France, Napoleon’s secular Université de France troubled Roman Catholics, because it threatened their educational monopoly. To wit, the Loi Falloux (Falloux Law) of 1850 attempted to reinstate some educational power to the Roman Catholic Church, but, by then, the Université de France had de facto substantive control of French higher education.45 Like-wise, in the UK, the new universities (i.e. the University of London), were non-denominational, and the Oxford Act of 1854 rid Oxford and Cambridge universities of required religion with a concomitant decline in chapel attendance, and of religion as integral to a university education.4647

The European university legacy

Ultimately, European research universities established the intellectual and academic traditions of university education world-wide; by the 19th century’s end, the Humboldtian university model was established in Europe, the US, and Japan.44 In the Americas, first the Spanish, then the British, and then the French founded universities in the lands they had conquered early in the 16th century, 48 meant to professionally educate their colonists and propagate monotheistic religion to establish formal, administrative rule of their American colonies; like-wise, the British in Canada, Australia, and the Cape Colony; and like-wise Japan, the Near East, and Africa. Those universities disseminated Western European science and technology and trained the natives to develop their countries resources;49 and, although most promoted the social, political, economic, and cultural aims of the imperial rulers, some promoted revolutionary development of the colonial societies.50 In the 20th century, urbanization and industrialization made a university education available to the mass populace.51 Throughout, the basic structure and research purposes of the universities have remained constant; per Clark Kerr, they “are among the least changed of institutions”.52

See also

Notes

  1. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. I, p. 5
  2. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. I, p. 6
  3. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100-1914, pp. 15–16
  4. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100-1914, p. 40
  5. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. II, p.30
  6. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. II, p. 7
  7. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. II, p. 15.
  8. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100-1914, p. 27
  9. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100-1914, p. 27-28
  10. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100-1914, p. 33
  11. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. II, p.8
  12. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100-1914, pp. 50–52
  13. ^ Rüegg, “Themes”, A History of the University in Europe, Vol. II, p.24.
  14. ^ Leff, “The Trivium and the Three Philosophies”, A History of the University in Europe, Vol. I, p.308.
  15. ^ (Rüegg v.2, p.22.
  16. ^ Rüegg, “Themes”, A History of the University in Europe, Vol. II, p.22.
  17. ^ Rüegg, “Themes”, A History of the University in Europe, Vol. II, pp.16–17.
  18. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100–1914, pp.99, 82.
  19. ^ Röhrs, "The Classical Idea of the University," Tradition and Reform of the University under an International Perspective p.20
  20. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p.5-6
  21. ^ Quoted in Christopher Clark, Iron Kingdom: The Rise and Downfall of Prussia, 1600-1947, p. 333
  22. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p.5-8
  23. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p.4-5
  24. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p.9
  25. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p.5
  26. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p.10
  27. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p.12
  28. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p.13
  29. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p.16
  30. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p.17-18
  31. ^ Rüegg, "Themes", A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p.31
  32. ^ Röhrs, “The Classical Idea of the University”, Tradition and Reform of the University under an International Perspective p.20.
  33. ^ Rüegg, “Themes”, A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p.21.
  34. ^ McCain, “Professors and Students in European Universities”, p. 204.
  35. ^ McCain, “Professors and Students in European Universities”, pp. 200, 204–06.
  36. ^ Bockstaele, "The mathematical and the exact sciences," A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p.512
  37. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100–1914, p. 117.
  38. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100–1914, pp. 118–19.
  39. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100–1914, pp. 121–24.
  40. ^ Charles, “Patterns”, A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p.59.
  41. ^ McCain, 206
  42. ^ Rüegg, “Themes”, A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p. 22.
  43. ^ Rüegg, “Themes”, A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p. 24.
  44. ^ a b Rüegg, “Themes”, A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III, p. 6.
  45. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100–1914, p. 113.
  46. ^ Rothblatt, “The Writing of University History at the End of Another Century”, p. 158.
  47. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100–1914, p. 114.
  48. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100–1914, p. 135.
  49. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100–1914, p.136.
  50. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100–1914, p. 138.
  51. ^ Rudy, The Universities of Europe, 1100–1914, pp. 136–37.
  52. ^ Trow, “The University at the End of the Twentieth Century”, Tradition and Reform of the University under an International Perspective p.323.

References

  • Charle, Christophe. “Patterns.” A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III: Universities In the Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Centuries. Ed. Walter Rüegg. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2004. 35-80.
  • McCain, James. “Professors and Students in European Universities: Observations of an American College President.” The Journal of Higher Education, Vol. 31, No.4. (Apr. 1960), pp. 200-207.
  • Röhrs, Hermann. “The Classical idea of the University- Its Origin and Significance as Conceived by Humboldt.” Tradition and Reform of the University under an International Perspective. Ed. Hermann Röhrs. New York: Berlag Peter Lang, 1987. 13-27.
  • Rothblatt, Sheldon. “The Writing of University History at the End of Another Century.” Oxford Review of Education, Vol. 23, No.2, “Writing University History.” (Jun. 1997), pp. 151-167.
  • Rudy, Willis. The Universities of Europe, 1100-1914. Cranbury, NJ: Associated University Presses, Inc., 1984.
  • Rüegg, Walter. “Themes.” A History of the University in Europe, Vol. I: Universities in the Middle Ages. Ed. Hilde de Ridder-Symoens. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1992. 3-34.
  • Rüegg, Walter. “Themes.” A History of the University in Europe, Vol. III: Universities In the Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Centuries. Ed. Walter Rüegg. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2004. 3-31.
  • Trow, Martin. “The University at the End of the Twentieth Century and Trends Toward Continued Development.” Tradition and Reform of the University under an International Perspective. Ed. Hermann Röhrs. New York: Berlag Peter Lang, 1987. 323-337.

External links








Creative Commons License