Jack Lyons (financier)
||This article includes a list of references, but its sources remain unclear because it has insufficient inline citations. (February 2011)|
After building up a substantial retail business, he was charged in 1987 in the Guinness share-trading fraud. He was convicted, stripped of his knighthood and CBE, and was heavily fined. Subsequent judgments from the European Court of Human Rights held that his trial was not fair. However, the convictions of Lyons and the other members of the Guinness Four were upheld by the Court of Appeal of England and Wales and the House of Lords.
Lyons was born in Leeds, where his father, an orthodox Jew who had immigrated from Poland in the 1880s, had established a men's clothing business, with a factory and a few dozen retail shops. Lyons attended Leeds Grammar School, leaving school at the age of 16, and later studied business at Columbia University (NYC). While there, war was declared and Lyons could not return to the UK so he enlisted in the Canadian army but because of his poor eyesight, he was confined to working in the Board of Trade. He met his future wife, singer Roslyn Rosenbaum, in Canada, and, in 1944, he became an assistant director of the country's Prices and Trade Board.1
Along with his brother Bernard, he contributed considerably to the growth of the family business after the war, with the expansion of branches and the development of a lucrative export division during the early post-war period. This enabled the business to grow rapidly into a large conglomerate of companies called United Drapery Stores, or UDS. By the 1960s, UDS Group had succeeded in taking the lead as the United Kingdom's top retailer, with a 1,300-strong empire of retail shops. Businesses within the UDS conglomerate included: Richard Shops, Allders of Croydon, John Collier, Timpsons, Alexandre Stores, John Blundell Credit Company, John Myers catalogue mail order business, Brooks Brothers, Peter Pell, Arding & Hobbs and Whiteleys department stores, Fifty Shilling Tailors and other department and duty-free stores. The number of men's suits sold in all UDS menswear shops in the year ending January 1967 was 1,119,000.
Within Allders alone growth continued throughout the 1970s to such an extent that in 1976 it became the third largest department store in the country, beaten only by Harrods and Selfridges. Meanwhile, the UDS Group had entered a new retail arena, that of the duty-free shop, when it acquired the licence to open and operate the shop at London's Heathrow airport. Attached to its Allders department store division, and later operated as Allders International, the UDS Group rapidly built up its network of duty-free shops around the world. In 1983, the UDS Group was sold to Hanson plc.
Lyons was accused of having used his personal friendship with Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher to ensure the Guinness brewing group's offer for Distillers in 1986 was approved by the Office of Fair Trading. Thatcher replied to a letter from Lyons saying the matter would be passed to the minister then responsible, Paul Channon. The bid was subsequently unblocked. Lyons also bought a substantial block of Distillers and Guinness shares in the lead-up to the bid, with a personal guarantee from Saunders that any future losses in the value of his shares would be paid by Guinness.
He was charged in 1987 in the Guinness share-trading fraud, along with Ernest Saunders, Gerald Ronson, and Anthony Parnes, and the four men became known as "the Guinness Four". He was convicted but not sent to prison because he was suffering from ill-health. However, he lost his knighthood and was fined £3,000,000 plus £1,000,000 prosecution costs.2
British prime minister John Major wrote to Lyons after revoking Lyons' knighthood in 1991: “It was painful for me to have to recommend that this be done, and I would not have inflicted this on you lightly. But the rules on forfeiture and the precedents left me, I regret, no alternative. May I assure you that the service which won you the honours in the first place is still appreciated and will never be forgotten.”
In 1995, on appeal, one count of conspiracy was quashed and his fine was cut to £2,500,000. (The refund cheque of £500,000 was inadvertently made out to 'Sir Jack Lyons', although by then he had lost his title). Lawyers for the Guinness Four said their clients had lost their right to silence because they were compelled to give evidence to Department of Trade and Industry inspectors. The prosecution countered that they should have nothing to hide, and that share markets have been regulated for centuries. Ultimately Lyons, Parnes and Ronson had relied entirely on Saunders whose plans had not been approved by Guinness's board of directors. Appeals by the four in 1991 and 1995 saw their convictions upheld.
When the DTI report was finally published in 1997, the BBC commented:
- Jack Lyons, who escaped prison on the alleged grounds of poor health (a growth in his urethra which a physician representing him claimed to be a large tumor), said: "Not a day has passed in the past 10 years when I have not asked myself the question `Why?' Why did I allow myself to become involved? Why did I fail to confirm whether these actions were lawful? Why did the Guinness lawyers not tell us that they weren't?" In an article for The Times, Mr Lyons said: "I simply do not believe that my actions were criminal ... I am, however, prepared to plead guilty to foolishness."
A third appeal in 2001 held by the European Court of Human Rights had ruled that the defendants were denied a fair trial by being compelled in law to provide potentially self-incriminatory information to Department of Trade and Industry inspectors which was then used as primary evidence against them. This breached their right to silence. The European Court stopped short of ruling that the men should have been acquitted. Parliament had amended the relevant law several years prior to the ECHR judgment to make evidence obtained under compulsion inadmissible; a court could still draw adverse inferences if a suspect remained silent.
At the time of the court of human rights verdict, Lyons said: "I welcome this judgment so that I may yet be able to enjoy a little of my retirement without the cloud of injustice hanging over me." See the Court of Appeal of England and Wales (2001 EWCA Crim 2860) and House of Lords (2002 UKHL 44) both upheld the convictions of the Guinness Four on the basis that subsequent changes in the law could not be taken into consideration in reassessing the convictions unless they were declared to have retrospective effect.citation needed
Lyons made philanthropic donations to hospitals, universities, and the arts.
The Sir Jack Lyons Concert Hall at the University of York is central to its music department. The department commemorated Lyons's 90th birthday with a special concert and dinner in York Minster on 28 June 2006. Lyons also contributed to the University's Music Research Centre and donated a research scholarship for PhD students.
The Sir Jack Lyons Theatre at the Royal Academy of Music in London was constructed with his donations. Lyons assisted in funding an exhibition of the works of Jacob Epstein at the Edinburgh Festival of 1961 after being approached by Lord Harewood, the Festival director. When the exhibition closed Lyons purchased some of the sculptures.
The Sir Jack Lyons Charitable Trust, has as its objectives, apart from the arts, concern for the poor, disadvantaged, and under-served; respect for diversity; promotion of understanding across cultures; and empowerment of communities in need.
Jack and Roslyn Lyons wed in 1943; the couple had two sons and two daughters. Jack Lyons died in 2008, aged 92.
- Obituary, Times Online, February 20, 2008.
- Guinness Four fail in fight for acquittal, BBC News, December 21, 2001.
- How they live now, Evening Standard, December 21, 2001.
- Guinness Four 'robbed of their right to silence', The Independent, December 4, 2001.
- "No hangovers for the three key characters", Daily Telegraph, November 28, 1997.
- "Remembering Jack Lyons", Peter Stothard, TimesOnline
- Obituary, Jewish Chronicle, February 29, 2008.
- Obituary, Daily Telegraph, February 21, 2008.
- "Life in the Shadow of Terror", art exhibit associated with Lyons
- York Press concert preview, announcing University of York birthday concert for Lyons
- York Press concert review, giving details of the event
- University of York press release, announcing new music scholarships sponsored by Lyons