Motoring taxation in the United Kingdom
|This article needs additional citations for verification. (November 2007)|
Motoring taxation in the United Kingdom consists primarily of vehicle excise duty (commonly known as VED, vehicle tax, car tax, and often incorrectly referred to as road tax), which is levied on vehicles registered in the UK and hydrocarbon oil duty (normally referred to as fuel tax) which is levied on the fuel used by motor vehicles. VED and fuel tax raised approximately GB£32 billion in 2009, a further £4 billion was raised from the value added tax on fuel purchases. Motoring-related taxes for fiscal year 2011/12, including fuel duties and VED, are estimated that will amount to more than GB£38 billion, representing almost 7% of total UK taxation.1
Road pricing in the form of congestion charges are in place in London and Durham. However these are generally viewed as usage charges rather than as tax for legal purposes although this interpretation is disputed by the USA and some other embassies in relation to the London congestion charge.2
- 1 History
- 2 Current taxes
- 3 Road usage charges
- 4 Proposed taxes and charges
- 5 See also
- 6 References
- 7 External links
The history of motoring taxation was closely linked to the construction of roads until 1937, since when motoring taxation has been treated as 'general taxation' with roads competing for funds with other departments on an equal basis.
In the early years of the Twentieth Century funding for roads and related infrastructure was drawn mainly from local ratepayers and the tram companies, who were obliged to maintain the road around their tracks under the Tramways Act of 1870. The price of fuel for steam engines had been subject to local coal duties until their abolition in 1889, and centrally controlled during World War I and World War II.
The Motor Car Act 1903 introduced the £1 (£91.00 as of 2013)3 registration fee for each motor vehicle, which were already also subject to carriage duty if they were not used solely for trade. Carriage duty was paid for a carriage licence which cost £2 2s. (£2.10) for vehicles weighing up to 1 ton, and £4 4s. (£4.20) for vehicles over 1 ton.4
A new duty was introduced in 1909 on "motor spirit" (imported petrol), leaving alternative fuels duty-free.5 The original 1909 rate was 3d per imperial gallon.6 The 'Road Board' was established in 1910 which could make grants for new roads to local authorities from the Road Improvement Fund as envisage by the Development and Road Improvement Funds Act 1909.7
The Roads Act 1920 required councils to register all new vehicles and to allocate a separate number to each vehicle and to Provision for the collection and application of the excise duties. The act also established the Road Fund. The Road Fund Licence (later renamed as Vehicle Excise Duty) was introduced in 1921citation needed and improve roads which had suffered as a consequence of the Great War.citation needed It was intended as charge that could be levied regardless of the fuel used to power a vehicle. The Minister of Transport was responsible for collecting and spending the money collected8 although in later years the Treasury assumed responsibility for the allocation of funds.
Increased transportation of freight by heavy road vehicles also increased the wear on roads and led first to a "wetted tax" for steam road locomotives, followed by the adoption of the recommendations of the Salter Report of 1933 for all heavy vehicles. This addressed a perception that the free use of roads was unfairly subsidising the railway's competitors, through the introduction of an additional axle weight duty within the VED in order to charge commercial motor vehicles for the costs they generated. There were exceptions for vehicles that seldom used public roads, such as agricultural tractors. This annual duty was payable by all road hauliers in proportion to the axle load and had the effect of removing many heavy steam-powered vehicles from the road. It was accompanied by changes in legislation that relieved local authorities of some of their costs through new abilities to set weight and speed limits.
The Road Fund was abolished on 1 April 1937 as a result of the Finance Act 1936,9 and motoring taxation being treated as general taxation since that date.
The Trunk Roads Act of 1936 had transferred management of 4,500 miles (7,200 km) of major 'Trunk roads' to the Ministry of Transport.
Since 1937 motoring taxation has been treated as 'general taxation' losing its direct connection to the funding of roads and motoring infrastructure.
The Smeed Report of 1962 suggested that road users should pay the costs that he imposes upon others", including road costs (construction, maintenance, lighting), congestion (the delay the motorist causes to others) and social costs (risk, noise, fumes).
In March of the same year motoring organisations appealed to the Chancellor of the Exchequer to reduce the "disturbingly high cost of motoring" by cutting motoring taxation in the forthcoming budget. Between 1950 and 1961 motoring tax revenue rose from £131 million (£3.8 billion as of 2013) to £730 million (£13.8 billion as of 2013).10 By 1966, when taxation revenue reached £1 billion the Royal Automobile Club were calling for an end to the "crippling spiral of motoring taxation", stating that less than one-third of the revenue was spent on road improvements.11
Following extensive and politically damaging road protests in the UK during the early 1990s (including the M11 link road and Twyford Down) the Conservative government introduced the Fuel Price Escalator, which were automatic fuel tax increases above inflation with an objective to stem the increase in pollution from road transport and cut the need for new road building. The policy was retained by the incoming Labour government in 1997 and was withdrawn after the fuel protests of 2000.12
In March 2005, a graduated vehicle excise duty system, with tax bands based on CO2 ratings, was introduced as an incentive to purchase vehicles with lower emission ratings.citation needed
In 2012 the government announced that it would announced that it was consulting on introducing HGV road user charging in order to ensure that foreign hauliers pay their fair share towards the upkeep of British roads.13
In spite of these protests, the country's economy and motorists' behaviour has generally become less sensitive to the price of fuel at the pump, with economists now estimating it to have a price elasticity of approximately -0.24,14 (thus an economist would expect that a doubling of the fuel price would only stop a quarter of journeys.)
Hydrocarbon oil duty, commonly referred to as 'fuel duty' or 'fuel tax' is an excise duty levied on some fuels used by road vehicles in the United Kingdom. Tax is based on fuel volume, rather than as a percentage of the selling price.15 With the exception of gas, rates don't vary by fuel type. Some vehicles including local bus services, some farm and construction vehicles and aviation pay reduced or no fuel duty. A fuel duty rebate is available for Bus transport in the United Kingdom. In May 2008, UK fuel taxes were the highest in Europe.16
Vehicle Excise Duty, also commonly known as 'VED', 'vehicle tax', 'car tax' and incorrectly referred to as 'road tax', is a vehicle road use tax levied as an excise duty which must be paid for most types of vehicle which are to be used (or parked) on the public roads in the United Kingdom.18 Motor vehicles used on public roads should display a current vehicle licence (tax disc) as proof of payment which will not be issued without prior proof that the vehicle has valid MOT and insurance. A 'Statutory Off Road Notification (SORN)' must be made for a registered vehicle that is not being used on the road, and which has been taxed since 31 January 1998.
VED was introduced in the 1888 budget; the current system, which applies specifically to motor vehicles was introduced in 1920 and was initially paid directly into the Road Fund which was ring-fenced for road construction until 1937, after which time it was treated as general taxation.19 Since 1999,20 the duty has been levied according to the CO2 emissions, starting with a reduced rate of £50,20 the scheme was extended into a graded system in 2001.21
The duty raised GB£5.63 billion in 2009.17
Customs duties on some Grey import vehicles and vehicle components or spares from outside the EU may be assessed at an additional charge which is then subject to VAT.
The value of a vehicle bought by a company for the dedicated use of its staff is treated as a taxable benefit for that individual, and assessed by HMRC with other income for income tax purposes. Until 2002 their financial benefit was assessed primarily based on price and mileage driven; this was then modified so that vehicles with lower emissions were assessed at a lower value than those with higher emissions. In addition, the taxable allowance for mileage using private cars has remained static.
A significant proportion of new vehicles are bought as company cars, thus this method of charging is not only aimed at encouraging companies to use "cleaner" vehicles, but, when sold on the second-hand market, these vehicles will filter through and raise the efficiency of the national 'fleet' .22
In London and in a small number of other places road usage charges in the form of road pricing, however these are generally viewed as 'usage charges' rather than as tax for legal purposes although this is disputed in relation to the London congestion charge by the USA and some other countries.2
The London congestion charge, which applied to most vehicles entering parts of Central London was introduced in 2003 with an extension into West London in 2007.2324 Since 4 July 2005 the normal daily charge has been £8.25 The total receipts from the London Congestion Charge for 2006-07 was £213 million (provisional figures), which, after operating costs, left £123m of hypothecated revenue for London transport schemes.26
Towards the end of 2006, the Mayor of London proposed the introduction of a variable congestion charge. Similarly to vehicle excise duty (VED), it would be based on emissions of carbon dioxide in grams/km. This would reduce or eliminate the charge for small and fuel-efficient vehicles, and increase it to up to £25 a day for large, inefficient vehicles such as SUVs, large saloons and compact MPVs with a Band G VED rating, that is, emissions of > 225 g/km of CO2. Electric zero-emissions vehicles are already exempt from the charge.2728
The London low emission zone, a pollution charge scheme, was introduced between February 2008 and January 2012 covering nearly all of Greater London29 Payment of the LEZ charge is in addition to any congestion charge required.30
In 2003 the Dartford Crossing construction debt was paid off, which should have resulted in the scrapping of the toll fee to cross. However, the government decided to continue to charge most crossing users to keep congestion levels down.31 Ironically, since the upgrading of the crossing doubled capacity in terms of road lanes, but did not add extra toll booths, it is the toll booths themselves that are responsible for lengthy queues at peak times,citation needed and removal of the booths would almost certainly reduce congestion. As with congestion charging schemes, all proceeds must be used for transport purposes. In one year this money amounted to £60 million.32
The UK's first privately operated motorway opened in 2003. The M6 Toll (originally the Birmingham Northern Relief Road) is designed to relieve the M6 through Birmingham, which is one of the most heavily used roads in the country.33
In 2005, the Government published proposals for a UK wide road pricing scheme. This was designed to be revenue neutral with other motoring taxes to be reduced to compensate.37 The plans have been extremely controversial with 1.8 million people signing a petition against them.38
Nottingham is proposing to become the first city in the UK to introduce a workplace parking levy. The scheme would result in a £185 per annum levy, rising to £350 by 2014, on each parking space made available to employees at businesses with more than ten such parking spaces. The council propose to use the revenue, which is forecast to be £12 million in the first year, to develop the city's tram system.39
A 2012 study by the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) funded by the RAC Foundation found that the government's drive to promote green vehicles with a lower carbon footprint could result in a significant loss of revenue from motoring taxes, estimated at GB£13 billion by 2029 at current prices, according to forecasts by the Office for Budget Responsibility. This revenue decline is partly due to improved vehicle efficiency and the growth of plug-in electric vehicles. Among the options available to the government to offset the loss, a further increase of the duty on gasoline and diesel or the introduction of new taxes on alternative energy sources such as electricity for vehicles were considered. However, due to lack of popularity of the former and the risks of hindering the entire green vehicle strategy, the IFS study recommended to introduce a nationwide system of road pricing to charge drivers by each mile driven, with higher pricing in congested areas at peak times, while reducing the existing motoring taxes. Under this strategy drivers in the countryside would be likely to pay less, as rural motorists are currently overtaxed according to the study.404142
- Paul Johnson, Andrew Leicester and George Stoye (May 2012). "Fuel for Thought - The what, why and how of motoring taxation". Institute for Fiscal Studies and Royal Automobile Club Foundation for Motoring. Retrieved 2012-05-20. Executive Summary, pp. ix.
- Mulholland, Helene (19 November 2008). "Foreign diplomats owe £23m over London congestion charge". The Guardian.
- UK CPI inflation numbers based on data available from Gregory Clark (2013), "What Were the British Earnings and Prices Then? (New Series)" MeasuringWorth.
- "The Motor the Fisc, and the Underwriter". The Times. 1906-12-11.
- "Petrol As Motor Spirit". The Times. 1909-05-07.
- Christine Buckley (2008-01-22). "Business piles on pressure over fuel duty rise". London: The Times. Retrieved 2008-01-27.
- "Records inherited and created by the Ministry of Transport, Roads and Highways Divisions and successors". National Archives.
- "The Budget, Mr. Chamberlain's Statement, New And Increased Taxes". The Times. 1920-04-20.
- "MINISTRY OF TRANSPORT. HC Deb 17 June 1938 vol 337 cc581-670". Hansard.
- "Average of £73 Yearly in Motor Taxation". The Times. 1962-03-09.
- "Taxation Screw on Motorist". The Times. 1966-02-23.
- "UK fuel tax: The facts". BBC News. 21 September 2001. Retrieved 13 April 2012. "The major change in petrol taxation came under the Conservatives in 1993 with the introduction of the Fuel Price Escalator. The escalator was designed as a means both to raise money and discourage car use on environmental grounds... While duty rose by two pence a litre as part of the 2000 Budget, Gordon Brown also scrapped the fuel price escalator, saying that future increases would be decided on the basis of the "due Budget proces"
- "Foreign lorries face £10 daily charge on UK roads". BBC News. "Foreign lorry drivers could pay as much as £10 a day to use UK roads, the government has announced. UK haulage firms already have to pay to make journeys in other European Union countries, including France. Transport Minister Mike Penning said charging overseas companies would create a "fairer" situation."
- "Oil Dependence: Is transport running out of affordable fuel?" (PDF). OECD - ITF. February 2008. p. 19.
- "Hydrocarbon Oils: Duty rates". UK HM Revenue & Customs. Retrieved 2008-01-27.
- Robert Winnett (2008-05-10). "UK drivers pay highest fuel taxes in Europe". The Daily Telegraph (Telegraph Media Group). Archived from the original on 2008-05-13. Retrieved 2008-05-14.
- United Kingdom National Accounts: The Blue Book (Report). Office for National Statistics. 2010.
- "The road user and the law". Direct.gov.uk. "Most of the provisions apply on all roads throughout Great Britain, although there are some exceptions."
- "Vehicle Excise Duties". Parliament Briefing Paper. Retrieved 2011-01-26.
- "Drivers paying Budget price". BBC News. 1999-03-12. Retrieved 2007-11-24.
- "lpgtax - epetition reply". Her Majesty's Government. 2007-03-09. Retrieved 2007-11-24.
- "Report on the Evaluation of the Company Car Tax Reform: Stage 2" (PDF). HMRC. 2006.
- "Congestion Charging Western Extension". Greater London Authority. Archived from the original on 2005-12-30. Retrieved 2006-04-08.
- Webster, Ben (2005-10-01). "Livingstone takes charge zone farther west despite opposition". The Times (London: News International Limited). Retrieved 2006-04-09.
- "Congestion charge increases to £8". BBC News (British Broadcasting Corporation). 2005-04-01. Retrieved 2006-05-25.
- "Central London Congestion Charging: Impacts monitoring: Fifth Annual Report" (PDF). Transport for London. July 2007. Retrieved 2008-01-28.
- "Q&A: The congestion charge". The Guardian (London: Guardian News and Media). 2006-08-07. Retrieved 2007-05-26.
- Webster, Ben (2006-07-13). "Congestion charge will rise to £25 for 'Chelsea tractors'". The Times (London: News Corporation Ltd). Retrieved 2007-05-26.
- "The Low Emission Zone. Cleaner air for Greater London." (PDF). Transport for London. pp. Pages 10–12. Retrieved 2007-11-25.
- "Area of operation". Transport for London. Retrieved 2007-11-25.
- "Motorists 'let down' by toll u-turn". BBC News. 2003-04-01. Retrieved 2007-11-23.
- "Call for tunnel to be made safer". BBC News. 2004-09-20. Retrieved 2007-11-24.
- "M6 Toll (formerly Birmingham Northern Relief Road)". The Motorway Archive. The Motorway Archive Trust. Retrieved 2007-11-18.
- "Toll road lawyers in award hope". BBC News. 2006-04-09. Retrieved 2007-11-23.
- "Statement of Accounts" (PDF). Durham County Council. March 2007. Retrieved 2008-02-03.dead link
- Samuel, Peter (2004-07-20). "UK road pricing could halve congestion but not feasible until 2015 - report". Toll Roads News. Retrieved 2007-11-25.
- "'Pay-as-you-go' road charge plan". BBC News. 2005-06-06. Retrieved 2007-11-18.
- "PM denies road toll 'stealth tax'". BBC News. 2007-02-21. Retrieved 2007-11-18.
- "Council pushes parking tax plan". BBC News (BBC). 2008-05-09. Retrieved 2008-05-18.
- "Compelling case for UK road charging, IFS study says". BBC News. 2012-05-14. Retrieved 2012-05-20.
- Gwyn Topham (2012-05-15). "Green cars will lead to fall in motoring revenue for Treasury, says study". The Guardian. Retrieved 2012-05-20.
- IFS (May 2012). "The road ahead for motoring taxes?". Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS). Retrieved 2012-05-20.