One Tree Hill (song)
|"One Tree Hill"|
|Single by U2|
|from the album The Joshua Tree|
|B-side||"Bullet the Blue Sky"
"Running to Stand Still"
|Recorded||July 1986 – January 1987 at Windmill Lane Studios in Dublin|
|U2 singles chronology|
"One Tree Hill" is a song by the rock band U2 and the ninth track on their 1987 album The Joshua Tree. In March 1988, it was released as the fourth single from the album in New Zealand and Australia, while "In God's Country" was released as the fourth single in North America. The release charted at number one on the New Zealand Singles Chart.
The track was written in memory of Greg Carroll, a Māori man the band first met in Auckland during The Unforgettable Fire Tour in 1984. He became very close friends with lead singer Bono and served as a roadie for the group. Carroll was killed in July 1986 in a motorcycle accident in Dublin. Following the funeral in New Zealand, Bono wrote the lyrics to "One Tree Hill", which he dedicated to Carroll. The lyrics reflect Bono's thoughts at the funeral and reflect on his first night in NZ when Greg took Bono up Auckland's One Tree Hill, as well as paying homage to Chilean activist Víctor Jara. Musically, the song was developed in a jam session with producer Brian Eno. The vocals were recorded in a single take, as Bono felt incapable of singing them a second time.
"One Tree Hill" was received favourably by critics, who variously described it as "a soft, haunting benediction",1 "a remarkable musical centrepiece",2 and a celebration of life.3 U2 delayed performing the song on the Joshua Tree Tour in 1987 because of Bono's fears over his emotional state. After its live debut on the tour's third leg and an enthusiastic reaction from audiences, the song was played occasionally for the rest of the tour and semi-regularly during the Lovetown Tour of 1989–1990. It has appeared only sporadically since then, and most renditions were performed in New Zealand. Performances in November 2010 on the U2 360° Tour were dedicated to the miners who died in the Pike River Mine disaster.
U2 first visited Australia and New Zealand in 1984 to open The Unforgettable Fire Tour.5 After a 24-hour flight into Auckland, lead singer Bono was unable to adjust to the time difference between New Zealand and Europe. During the night, he left his hotel room and met some people who showed him around the city. Greg Carroll was part of that group: he had met U2's production manager Stever Iredale and been offered a job helping the band for their upcoming concert on account of Greg's experience with local rock bands. They ended up taking Bono up One Tree Hill, the highest - and more spiritually significant to Māori people - of Auckland's largest volcanoes.67 Greg worked as a stage hand gently stopping people getting on stage, and was described as "this very helpful fellah running around the place".4 U2's manager Paul McGuinness thought Carroll was so helpful that he should accompany the band for the remainder of the tour.8 The group helped him obtain a passport, and he subsequently joined them on the road in Australia and the United States as their assistant.79 He became very close friends with Bono and his wife Ali Hewson, and following the conclusion of the tour, he worked for U2 in Dublin.48
On 3 July 1986,11 just before the start of the recording sessions for The Joshua Tree, Carroll was killed in a motorcycle accident while on a courier run. A car had pulled in front of him, and unable to stop in the rain, Carroll struck the side of the car and was killed instantly.8 The event shocked the entire band; drummer Larry Mullen, Jr. said, "his death really rocked us – it was the first time anyone in our working circle had been killed."9 Guitarist The Edge said, "Greg was like a member of the family, but the fact that he had come under our wing and had travelled so far from home to be in Dublin to work with us made it all the more difficult to deal with."12 Bassist Adam Clayton described it as "a very sobering moment", saying, "it inspired the awareness that there are more important things than rock 'n' roll. That your family, your friends and indeed the other members of the band – you don't know how much time you've got left with them."812 Bono said, "it was a devastating blow. He was doing me a favour. He was taking my bike home."8 He later commented, "it brought gravitas to the recording of The Joshua Tree. We had to fill the hole in our heart with something very, very large indeed, we loved him so much."12 Accompanied by Bono, Ali, Mullen, and other members of the U2 organisation, Carroll's body was flown back to New Zealand and buried in the traditional Māori manner at Kai-iwi Marae.811 Bono sang "Let It Be" and "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" for him at the funeral.11
Shortly after returning to Dublin, Bono wrote lyrics for a song about the funeral that he titled "One Tree Hill" after the hill he remembered from his visit to Auckland in 1984.11 The music was developed early in the recording sessions for The Joshua Tree. The Edge said, "We were jamming with Brian [Eno]. He was playing keyboards ... we just got this groove going, and this part began to come through. It's almost highlife, although it's not African at all ... the sound was for me at that time a very elaborate one. I would never have dreamt of using a sound like that before then, but it just felt right, and I went with it."13 Bono recorded his vocals in a single take, as he felt that he could not sing the lyrics a second time.14 Three musicians from Toronto, Dick, Paul and Adele Armin, recorded string pieces for the song in Grant Avenue Studio in Hamilton, Ontario. In a six-hour phone call with The Edge, and under the supervision of producer Daniel Lanois, the Armins used "sophisticated 'electro-acoustic' string instrument[s]" they developed called Raads to record a piece created for the song.15 Dick Armin said, "[U2] were interested in using strings, but not in the conventional style of sweetening. They didn't want a 19th-century group playing behind them."15 Bono found the song so emotional, he was unable to listen to it after it had been recorded.16
In the song, Bono included the lyric: "Jara sang, his song a weapon in the hands of love / You know his blood still cries from the ground". This refers to the Chilean political activist and folk singer Víctor Jara, who become a symbol of the resistance against the Augusto Pinochet government after he was tortured and killed during the 1973 Chilean coup d'état.17 Bono learned of Jara after meeting René Castro, a Chilean mural artist, while on Amnesty International's A Conspiracy of Hope tour. Castro had been tortured and held in a concentration camp for two years by the dictatorial Chilean government because his artwork criticised the Pinochet-led regime that had seized power in 1973 during the coup.18 While purchasing a silkscreen of Martin Luther King, Jr. that Castro had created, Bono noticed a print of Jara.1719 He became more familiar with him after reading Una Canción Truncada (A Truncated Song), written by Jara's widow Joan Turner.17
Thirty-second sample of "One Tree Hill" containing lyrical references to Victor Jara and the funeral of Greg Carroll
|Problems playing this file? See media help.|
"One Tree Hill" runs for 5 minutes, 23 seconds. It is played in common time at a tempo of 120 beats per minute.23 The song begins with a highlife-influenced riff by The Edge on guitar, which repeats in the background throughout the song.1723 Percussion from drummer Larry Mullen, Jr. enters after two seconds. At 0:07, a second guitar enters. At 0:15, Clayton's bass and Mullen's drums enter, and at 0:31, the verse chord progression of C–F–B♭–F–C is introduced.1723 The first verse begins at 0:47. At 1:32, the song moves to the chorus, switching to a C–B♭–F–C chord progression. The second verse then begins at 1:49, and after the second chorus, a brief musical interlude begins at 2:36, in which The Edge's guitar is replaced by the Raad strings.17 The third verse begins at 3:07, and The Edge's guitar resumes at 3:38 in the chorus. A guitar solo begins at 4:16 and is played until the instrumentation comes to a close at 4:36. After two seconds of silence, the Raad strings fade in and Bono proceeds to sing the coda. The final lyric and strings fade out over the final six seconds.17
Clayton called it part of a trilogy of songs on the album, along with "Bullet the Blue Sky" and "Mothers of the Disappeared", that decry the involvement of the United States in the Chilean coup.17 McGuinness stated that the imagery in the song described the sense of tragedy felt by the band over Carroll's death.14 Colm O'Hare of Hot Press believed The Edge's guitar riff personified the lyric "run like a river runs to the sea".13 Thom Duffy of the Orlando Sentinel felt the song reflected the seduction of a lover.24 Richard Harrington of the Washington Post acknowledged the tribute to Carroll, adding that it demonstrated U2's belief that music could spur change.25
Like many other U2 songs, "One Tree Hill" can be interpreted in a religious manner. Hot Press editor Niall Stokes called it "a spiritual tour de force", saying "it is a hymn of praise and celebration which described the traditional Māori burial of their friend on One Tree Hill and links it poetically with themes of renewal and redemption."8 Beth Maynard, a Church rector from Fairhaven, Massachusetts, felt the song "vows faith in the face of loss, combining elegiac lines about a friend ... and the martyred Chilean activist and folk singer Victor Jara, with a subtle evocation of end-time redemption and a wrenching wail to God to send the pentecostal Latter Rain."26 Matt Soper, Senior Minister of the West Houston Church of Christ, believed the lyrics were an attempt by Bono to understand God's place in the world.27 Steve Stockman, a chaplain at Queen's University Belfast, felt that the song alluded to "transcendent places beyond the space and time of earth".28 Music journalist Bill Graham noted "the lyrics, with their reference to traditional Māori burial ceremonies on One Tree Hill, indicated that the band's faith didn't exclude an empathy with others' beliefs and rituals. Their Christianity wouldn't plaster over the universal archetypes of mourning."3
"One Tree Hill" was released as a 7-inch single in New Zealand22 and Australia29 in March 1988. The cover art (photographed by Anton Corbijn), sleeve (designed by Steve Averill), and B-sides ("Bullet the Blue Sky" and "Running to Stand Still") were identical to those used for U2's 1987 single "In God's Country", released only in North America.2230 A cassette single, available only in New Zealand, was also released.31 The song reached number one on the New Zealand Singles Chart.32 "One Tree Hill" was included as a bonus track on the Japanese version of U2's 1998 compilation album, The Best of 1980–1990.21 The accompanying video compilation included the song's music video, directed by Phil Joanou, which features a live performance taken from a previously unreleased cut of U2's 1988 rockumentary Rattle and Hum.33 Another rendition was available on the 2004 digital live album Live from the Point Depot.34
"One Tree Hill" was received favourably by critics. Hot Press editor Niall Stokes described it as one of U2's best tracks, calling it a "fitting tribute" to Carroll.8 The Toronto Star felt it was one of the best songs on the album.15 Steve Morse of The Boston Globe compared Bono's vocals at the song's conclusion to the passion of American soul singer Otis Redding, also noting that the coda was reminiscent of the hymn "Amazing Grace".35 Steve Pond of Rolling Stone called it "a soft, haunting benediction".1 Bill Graham of Hot Press said the song was "hopeful, not grim", describing the lyric "We run like a river to the sea" as "[musician Mike Scott's] metaphor recast in terms of eternal life and the Maori's own belief."36 He described The Edge's playing as "a loose-limbed guitar melody with both an African and a Hawaiian tinge", concluding by saying "despite its moving vocal coda, 'One Tree Hill' isn't sombre. It celebrates the life of the spirit not its extinction."3
Writing for The New York Times, John Rockwell felt that it was an example of U2 stretching their range, saying "the inclusion of musical idioms [is] never so overtly explored before on a U2 record, especially the gospel chorus of 'One Tree Hill'".37 Colin Hogg of The New Zealand Herald called it "a remarkable musical centrepiece", believing it to be the best song on the album.2 Colm O'Hare of Hot Press said it was "arguably the most poignant, emotionally-charged song U2 have ever recorded."38 He added that it was the "least instrumentally adorned song on the album, resplendent in a feeling of space and openness."13 McGuinness called it one of his favourite U2 songs.39
"One Tree Hill" made its live debut on 10 September 1987 in Uniondale, New York, the opening night of the third leg of the Joshua Tree Tour, where it opened the encore.42 The song had been left out of the set up to this point because Bono feared he would be unable to overcome his emotions in the live setting.42 Despite his fears, the song received an enthusiastic reaction from the audience.42 It was performed a further six times and then dropped from the show for a period of two months. It was revived in the main set on 17 November 1987 in Los Angeles, California, and played a further nine times on the tour.43 "One Tree Hill" was played occasionally on the Lovetown Tour, appearing at 19 of 47 concerts.44 The penultimate performance, on 31 December 1989, was broadcast live on radio to 21 countries throughout Europe as a New Year's Eve present from the band.45
"One Tree Hill" was absent during the majority of the Zoo TV Tour, only appearing as an extended snippet at the end of "One" at both concerts in New Zealand in 1993.46 It did not appear again until 24 November 2006 in Auckland, New Zealand, on the final leg of the Vertigo Tour. It was considered to close the concert, but tour designer Willie Williams voiced concern as it had not been performed in full since 1990. The song was performed before "Sometimes You Can't Make It on Your Own" in the main set instead.47 U2 performed it an additional three times on the tour.48 "One Tree Hill" was absent for the majority of the U2 360° Tour but was revived in November 2010 for two concerts in New Zealand, where it was dedicated to the miners who died in the Pike River Mine disaster; their names were displayed on the video screen during the song.4950 Dedicating the song, Bono said, "we wrote it for Greg Carroll, whose family are with us tonight. But tonight it belongs to the miners of the West Coast Pike River."51 U2 played "One Tree Hill" on 25 March 2011, in Santiago, Chile, in a duet with Francisca Valenzuela, and they dedicated it to Victor Jara.52 Its final performance was on 5 July 2011 in Chicago, Illinois, where it was dedicated to Greg Carroll to commemorate the 25th anniversary of his death.53
In 2009, when asked about the likelihood of U2 performing the song, The Edge said, "it's one we kind of keep for special occasions, like playing New Zealand."54 Bono added, "it's a very special song that holds inside of it a lot of strong feelings, and I don't know if we're afraid of it or something, but we should be playing it more."54 McGuinness said that U2 found it difficult to play live.39
All lyrics written by Bono, all music composed by U2.
|7" vinyl,2229 cassette31|
|1.||"One Tree Hill"||5:23|
|2.||"Bullet the Blue Sky"||4:32|
|3.||"Running to Stand Still"||4:20|
|New Zealand Singles Chart32||1|
- Pond, Steve (9 April 1987). "Review: The Joshua Tree". Rolling Stone (497). Archived from the original on 30 January 2010.
- Hogg, Colin (20 March 1987). "Album review: The Joshua Tree". The New Zealand Herald. Archived from the original on 1 February 2011. Retrieved 1 February 2011. "... not only is it a song that means a lot in this part of the world, but it is the album's finest, saddest melody and its most heartfelt performance, building in urgency until Bono's voice just explodes to the song's climax."
- Graham (2004), pp. 34–35
- McCormick (2006), p. 157
- de la Parra (2003), pp. 52–54
- Stokes (2005), p. 74
- Kootnikoff (2010), p. 46
- Stokes (2005), p. 75
- McCormick (2006), p. 177
- "One Tree Hill loses its tree". BBC News. 26 October 2000. Archived from the original on 25 September 2011. Retrieved 25 September 2011.
- de la Parra (2003), p. 78
- McCormick (2006), p. 178
- O'Hare, Colm (21 November 2007). "The Secret History of 'The Joshua Tree' 15/18". Hot Press. Archived from the original on 26 September 2011. Retrieved 26 September 2011.
- Paul McGuinness; John Caddel (9 December 2007). Interview with Paul McGuinness (Radio broadcast). Dublin: Phantom FM. Dublin Rock Radio Ltd. Event occurs at 5:50.
- "Trio gives U2 Raad-ical strings". Toronto Star. 20 March 1987. p. D14.
- Kootnikoff (2010), pp. 60–61
- The Joshua Tree 20th anniversary edition (Boxset). Canada: Island Records. 2007. B0010304-00.
- de la Parra (2003), p. 76
- Mueller, Andrew (April 2009). "The Joshua Tree". The Ultimate Music Guide (Uncut) (U2): 59.
- Irwin, Colin (14 March 1987). "Once, we were asked to set up an audience with the Pope ...". Melody Maker. Reprinted in Jones, Allan, ed. (April 2009). The Ultimate Music Guide (Uncut) (U2): 60–69.
- The Joshua Tree (Vinyl). United Kingdom: Island Records. 1987. U2 6.
- (7" vinyl). "One Tree Hill". U2. New Zealand. 1988. 878 302-7.
- Chipkin (1999), pp. 69–77
- Duffy, Thom (22 March 1987). "U2". Orlando Sentinel. Archived from the original on 26 September 2011. Retrieved 26 September 2011.
- Harrington, Richard (22 March 1987). "U2 Can Be Famous; Breaking Into the Big Time With 'Joshua Tree'". The Washington Post. p. G1.
- Whiteley (2003), p. 170
- Soper (2010), p. 72
- Stockman (2005), p. 68
- (7" vinyl) (Release notes). "One Tree Hill". U2. Australia: Island Records. 1988. K-338.
- (12" vinyl) (Release notes). "In God's Country". U2. Canada: Island Records. IS-1167.
- (7" vinyl) (Release notes). "One Tree Hill". U2. New Zealand: Island Records. 1988. 878 302-4.
- "U2 – One Tree Hill". Ultratop. Retrieved 24 November 2009.
- Bono, The Edge, Adam Clayton, Larry Mullen, Jr. (April 1999). The Best of 1980–1990 (Videotape). PolyGram.
- Live from the Point Depot (Digital download). Island Records. 2004.
- Morse, Steve (1 March 1987). "U2's The Joshua Tree: A Spiritual Progress Report". The Boston Globe. p. B32. "[Bono's] emotional outpouring at the end ... has a passion on a par with peak-period Otis Redding. The song eventually winds down to a gospel improvisation that recalls the tenderness of 'Amazing Grace'."
- Graham, Bill (February 1987). "The Joshua Tree". Hot Press. Archived from the original on 26 September 2011. Retrieved 26 September 2011.
- Rockwell, John (29 March 1987). "U2 makes a bid for 'great band' status". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 25 September 2011. Retrieved 25 September 2011.
- O'Hare, Colm (21 November 2007). "The Secret History of 'The Joshua Tree' 14/18". Hot Press. Archived from the original on 26 September 2011. Retrieved 26 September 2011.
- "Absolute McGuinness". Propaganda (7). October 1987.
- "Building a Winning Team: The Making of One Tree Hill". One Tree Hill: The Complete First Season (Documentary). Warner Bros. 2005.
- Breskin, David (8 October 1987). "Interview with Bono". Rolling Stone.
- de la Parra (2003), p. 111
- de la Parra (2003), pp. 117–121
- de la Parra (2003), pp. 123–138
- de la Parra (2003), p. 135
- de la Parra (2003), p. 172
- Williams, Willie (24 November 2006). "Willie's Diary: Show Day, Auckland". U2.com. Live Nation. Retrieved 25 September 2011. (subscription required)
- Cohen, Jonathon (6 January 2007). "From Joshua Trees to Palm Trees". Billboard (Nielsen Business Media) 119 (1): 16–17. ISSN 0006-2510.
- "November 25, 2010: Auckland, NZ (Mt. Smart Stadium) show report". U2.com. Live Nation. 25 November 2010. Archived from the original on 25 September 2011. Retrieved 25 September 2011.
- Russell, Nicholas (26 November 2010). "U2 tribute to lost coal miners touches New Zealand". Sydney Morning Herald. Archived from the original on 25 September 2011. Retrieved 26 November 2010.
- "November 26, 2010: Auckland, NZ (Mt. Smart Stadium) show report". U2.com. Live Nation. 26 November 2010. Archived from the original on 25 September 2011. Retrieved 25 September 2011.
- "March 25, 2011: Santiago, CL (Estadio Nacional) show report". U2.com. Live Nation. 25 March 2011. Archived from the original on 25 September 2011. Retrieved 25 September 2011.
- "July 5, 2011: Chicago, IL, US (Soldier Field) show report". U2.com. Live Nation. 5 July 2011. Archived from the original on 25 September 2011. Retrieved 25 September 2011.
- Bono; The Edge (2 September 2010). Exclusive Interview with Bono and The Edge (Radio broadcast). New Zealand: The Rock. MediaWorks New Zealand. Event occurs at 4:16.
- Chipkin, Kenn (1999). U2 – The Joshua Tree: Authentic Record Transcriptions. London: Alfred Music Publishing. ISBN 978-0-7119-1315-8.
- de la Parra, Pimm Jal (2003). U2 Live: A Concert Documentary (second ed.). New York: Omnibus Press. ISBN 978-0-7119-9198-9.
- Graham, Bill; van Oosten de Boer, Caroline (2004). U2: The Complete Guide to Their Music. London: Omnibus Press. ISBN 0-7119-9886-8.
- Kootnikoff, David (2010). U2: A Musical Biography. Santa Barbara: Greenwood Press. ISBN 0-313-36523-7.
- Soper, Matt (2010). Raising Up a Testimony: Essays on Christianity in America. Longwood, Florida: Xulon Press. ISBN 978-1-60957-818-3.
- Stockman, Steve (2005). Walk On: The Spiritual Journey of U2 (Revised ed.). Orlando: Relevant Books. ISBN 0-9760357-5-8.
- Stokes, Niall (2005). U2: Into The Heart: The Stories Behind Every Song (Third ed.). New York: Thunder's Mouth Press. ISBN 1-56025-765-2.
- U2 (2006). McCormick, Neil, ed. U2 by U2. London: HarperCollins. ISBN 0-00-719668-7.
- Whiteley, Raewynne J.; Maynard, Beth (2003). Get Up Off Your Knees: Preaching the U2 Catalog. The New Church's Teachings. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Cowley Publications. ISBN 978-1-56101-223-7.