Vancouver Grizzlies relocation to Memphis
The Vancouver Grizzlies relocation to Memphis was a successful effort by the ownership group of the Vancouver Grizzlies to move the basketball team from the Canadian city of Vancouver, British Columbia, to the U.S. city of Memphis, Tennessee. The team began play as the Memphis Grizzlies in the 2001–02 season. It was the first of three National Basketball Association (NBA) franchise moves between 2001 and 2008, and the third of four major league teams to relocate from Canada to the United States between 1995 and 2005.
The Grizzlies had been created as an expansion team along with the Toronto Raptors in 1995. For the six seasons in Vancouver, the Grizzlies performed poorly; it only once finished better than last in the Midwest Division and never reached the playoffs. The Grizzlies were owned by Orca Bay Sports and Entertainment, who also owned the Vancouver Canucks of the National Hockey League (NHL). In 1999, Bill Laurie, owner of the NHL team St. Louis Blues, attempted to buy the Grizzlies, with the intent to move it to St. Louis. After interference by the NBA, the Grizzlies were sold to Michael Heisley. He immediately started the process to relocate the team, and seven US cities were candidates for the team—Anaheim, Buffalo, Memphis, New Orleans, Louisville, Las Vegas and San Diego—before settling on the move to Memphis at the end of the season.
The first four Grizzlies seasons had given average attendance in the middle third of the league. However, the last two seasons saw a reduction to among the league's lowest attendances; participating reasons were the teams poor performance and the 1998–99 NBA lockout. Contributing to the conditions for relocation were a weak Canadian dollar, unwillingness of some US players to live in Canada, and lack of local ownership. As of 2011, the current Canucks owners have announced interest to relocate another NBA team to Vancouver.citation needed
Memphis has previously had a different major basketball team, in the NBA predecessor American Basketball Association. Founded as the New Orleans Buccaneers in 1967, the franchise moved to Memphis in 1970, becoming the Memphis Pros. The team changed its name to the Memphis Tams and then the Memphis Sounds, before folding in 1975.1
The Grizzlies were created as an expansion team for the 1995–96 season which, along with the creation of the Toronto Raptors, saw the NBA expand into Canada. The Grizzlies were owned by Vancouver Canucks owner Arthur Griffiths. His company was in the process of building General Motors Place (GM Place) for the Canucks, and saw the Grizzlies as an additional tenant.2 Both Canadian teams (the Vancouver Grizzlies and the Toronto Raptors) were hampered by the NBA's decision to deny them one of the top five picks in the first draft, and the teams would not be allowed a top draft pick in the following three seasons, even if they should win the lottery. The teams were also hindered from using their full salary cap the first two seasons.3 For all six seasons in Vancouver, the Grizzlies had a terrible record. They finished seventh of seven in five seasons, and claimed one sixth place in the Midwest Division, never close to reaching the playoffs. The team won 101 games and lost 359, giving a winning percentage of .220.4
On 7 March 1995, the majority of the holding company was sold from Griffiths to Seattle-based John McCaw, Jr.2 On 12 November 1996, McCaw bought the rest of company. He stated that he was committed to retaining the team in Vancouver.5 Griffiths was forced to sell the Canucks and Grizzlies following the cost overruns that occurred on GM Place, and the expansion fees to start the Grizzlies had made his company illiquid.6
In 1999, McCaw started attempts to sell either Orca Bay or the Grizzlies, and at first negotiated an agreement with Dennis Washington, owner of Seaspan, who had a large portion of his operations in Vancouver. Washington initially agreed to purchase 50 percent of Orca Bay, with the intent of keeping the teams in Vancouver. Instead, McCaw used Washington's bid to leverage a higher sales price with Bill Laurie, who offered US$148 million for the Grizzlies, and a US$52 million bonus if the team ultimately relocated to St. Louis.7 The announcement was made in September 1999, one month after Laurie had bought the NHL team St. Louis Blues and their home venue Kiel Center (now Scottrade Center). St. Louis had not been the home of an NBA franchise since the St. Louis Hawks relocated to become the Atlanta Hawks in 1968.8 Kiel Center had annual sell-out for 15 to 17 basketball games for the Saint Louis University Billikens.9
After the deal was announced, NBA Commissioner David Stern stated that he was opposed to a relocation, showing to that no NBA franchise had moved since the mid-1980s. He stated that his goal was that the Grizzlies remain in Vancouver and succeed there. The NBA Board of Governors' Finance Committee also made negative statements, as the purchase agreement was structured with incentives to move the team. The deal was then renegotiated before the board could vote on the issue. On 21 January 2001, Laurie announced that he had paid McCaw an undisclosed amount to walk away from the deal.10
Four days later, on 25 January, it was announced that the Grizzlies was sold to Chicago-based Michael Heisley for US$160 million. At a press conference, he stated that he had the support of Stern, that he was committed to keeping the franchise in Vancouver, to making it a winning team, and that he was an owner that was committed to the market.11
Dick Versace, the Grizzlies' president of basketball operations, stated in the final Vancouver season that the company was losing US$40 million per season. These numbers were questioned by Richard Peddie, CEO of the Raptors, as the Grizzlies had a salary cap of US$48 million.12 Retrospectively, Heisley stated that he lost US$87 million on owning the Grizzlies, although that included a US$30 million relocation fee to the NBA.6 Versace stated that he felt that the team did not get sufficient support from the business community. Colin Jones, University of Victoria professor in sports economics, stated that it was difficult to attract corporate sponsors as long as the team was losing so many games; the Grizzlies lack of good draft picks lead to the team failing to win, thus losing revenue. He also noted that the team never sought help in the general business community regarding management issues.12
Stu Jackson, general manager for the first five seasons, made several non-optimal player selection decisions. This included selecting Bryant Reeves in the 1995 Draft, and signing him to a US$65 million six-year contract extension in 1997, putting the Grizzlies in a salary cap squeeze. From then he consequently drafted point guards, including Antonio Daniels, who failed to develop. Jackson traded a 2003 first-round pick for Otis Thorpe, who "hated Vancouver". He signed free agent Tony Massenburg for US$1.5 million, just to sign Isaac Austin for US$5.5 million and leave Massenburg on the bench.12 Griffiths retrospectively stated that the draft conditions from the NBA did not allow the franchise to build a winning team in years, and that the NBA had asked too high a price for not providing the means of a suitable income.6 On the other hand, the Raptors succeeded in drafting Vince Carter, reached the playoffs in the 1999–2000 season and played for a sell-out crowd.12
The location of the team in Canada was a major contributor; at the time the exchange rate was 67 US cents to the Canadian dollar. Because revenue was collected in Canadian dollars but player and coach salaries were paid in US dollars, the team ended up spending an undue amount of its revenue on salaries.6 The 1998–99 lockout was the pivoting point for home game attendance. While the whole league experienced a drop in attendance after the lockout, Vancouver experienced an even larger fall.13 The average attendance in 1997–98 was 16,108, ranking 16th in the league,14 while it fell to 13,899 in 1999–00, ranking 27th.15
Retrospectively, Griffiths stated that Heisley intentionally ran the team financially aground by alienating people, running insufficient marketing, and claiming basketball did not work in Vancouver. While running the team, Griffiths had not lost "millions and millions" and he stated that Vancouver had a better fan base than most NBA teams. The statements were denied by Heisley.6
With the public announcement in mid-February of the possible relocation of the team, Heisley and representatives for the Grizzlies set out on a road trip to consider several US cities which wanted to have the franchise relocate to their city.16 Originally Heisley had until 1 March to apply to the NBA for a relocation,17 but the deadline was later extended to 26 March. A similar deadline was also awarded to the Charlotte Hornets, who were also considering a relocation.16
In February 2001, the Louisville Board of Aldermen contacted the Grizzlies in an attempt to relocate the team to Louisville, Kentucky. The city lacked a suitable venue, but state and local officials agreed to build a new US$200 million arena if the NBA franchise relocate to the city. In addition, Tricon Global Restaurants (now Yum! Brands) would offer Heisley US$5 million per year for 20 years to locate the team in Louisville.18
The Memphis relocation effort was led by AutoZone founder Pitt Hyde, who promised to purchase 50% of the team. The city had a 1991 venue, Pyramid Arena, which could be used as a temporary home until a new US$250 million venue was ready for use in 2004. The venue would be publicly financed through sales tax rebates, government-backed bonds and hotel and car rental taxes. The Memphis efforts to get an NBA team had started in 1997, following the relocation of the Tennessee Titans of the National Football League to Nashville.1920
New Orleans, Louisiana mayor Marc Morial stated that he had approached Heisley in an attempt to attract the Grizzlies to his city. The city had opened the US$114 million New Orleans Arena in 1999, and offered it as a home to the franchise. Metrovision, the area's economic development chamber, stated that they had secured guarantees for purchasing suites, season tickets and club seating from businesses to the extent that there was a waiting list for suites. Also a relocation to St. Louis, under the same conditions as with Laurie, was considered.17
Another option was to relocate to Anaheim, California, in Greater Los Angeles. The Houston Rockets had looked into relocation to Anaheim the previous season, with Arrowhead Pond of Anaheim (now Honda Center) as the home venue. However, the NHL team then known as the Mighty Ducks of Anaheim had an agreement that any other tenant at the Pond should share revenues with their then-owner, The Walt Disney Company, although Disney stated they were willing to negotiate the terms. There are also two existing clubs in Los Angeles, the Lakers and the Clippers, which would make the media market small and limit revenue.21
Buffalo, New York announced interest in attracting the Grizzlies. The city had an appropriate venue in HSBC Arena (now First Niagara Center), home of the NHL team Buffalo Sabres. Mayor Anthony Masiello, a former college basketball star, stated that the attempt was "a long shot", but worth the try. The city previously had an NBA franchise in the Buffalo Braves, which was relocated to become the San Diego Clippers in 1978.22 The Clippers moved to Los Angeles in 1984, and San Diego was also mentioned as a potential site for the Grizzlies, although the city lacked a suitable venue.21 Las Vegas, Nevada was visited by Hainsley, where he negotiated with Mayor Oscar Goodman. The city offered the team free land for a new arena, but would not pay for construction. The other issue was Stern's demand that casinos stop accepting bets on NBA games as a precondition of placing a team in Las Vegas.16
The strongest bids were Memphis, Louisville, Anaheim and New Orleans. As the latter two had venues in place, they were seen as having an edge on the other two. Both Memphis and Louisville needed public funding for a new venue, and in either city, the team would have to play in a sub-optimal location for several seasons. However, the construction of a new venue was seen as an advantage by the Grizzlies, as it could be tailor-made for basketball, and the team would be able to control all revenue. The team also expected the highest local radio and television broadcasting rights in Louisville and Memphis, and that the two cities lacked other Big Four major league teams, granting the team preferred air times and increased attention from fans and media.23 A 2000 report from PricewaterhouseCoopers concluded with small cities often had higher attendance than larger cities because of team's professional league exclusivity. It also pointed to the strong support for college basketball in Tennessee and Kentucky.24
In Vancouver, the organization Save the Grizzlies was established to find a local investor to purchase the team.16 Led by among others Peter Ufford, they had a plan to create a public entity which could take over ownership of the team. Ufford retrospectively stated that had the attempt been given more time, they may have been able to secure a deal to keep the team in town, but that the relocation decision came too quickly for any plan to be finalized. Heisley stated that he had been willing to sell the team with a 30 percent discount to a Vancouver investor if he could secure a guarantee that the team would remain in town.6
On 26 March 2001, Heisley announced that he had selected Memphis.25 Memphis and Louisville were the most promising cities, with Heisley selecting Memphis because it offered a better deal and because of poor local executive leadership in Louisville.24 The choice would still have to be studied by a five-member NBA group before permission was granted from the league.25 The team's final match at GM Place was a 95–100 loss against the Houston Rockets on 14 April; final match overall was a road 95–81 win against the Golden State Warriors on 18 April.26
The NBA Relocation Committee gave its approval for the move to Memphis in late June, and on 4 July the Board of Governors unanimously approved the relocation. This also permitted Hyde to purchase a minority share of the franchise. By then the team administration had already relocated, and the day before the final decision, the team set up its rookie camp at Rhodes College. A relocation party was held on 7 July. A week before the move, the Grizzlies traded away two of the top players, Shareef Abdur-Rahim and guard Mike Bibby, who therefore never played for the Memphis Grizzlies.27
The move to Memphis did not solve the Grizzlies' financial problems, and as of 2011 the team's cumulative loss was US$100 million. The team did manage a 50-win season,6 reach the playoff four times, but failed to advance in the playoffs until the 2010–11 season.4 As of 2011, the Grizzlies remain, according to Forbes, the third least-valuable NBA franchise, at US$266 million.6 Attendance never exceeded Vancouver levels; in the inaugural season the Memphis Grizzlies had an average of 13,737 spectators,28 and in the 2010–11 season had 14,650.29
The Grizzlies were the first NBA relocation since the Kansas City Kings relocated to become the Sacramento Kings in 1985.27 It was followed by two others in the same decade, with the Charlotte Hornets relocating to become the New Orleans Hornets (now Pelicans) in 2002,30 and the Seattle SuperSonics relocating to become the Oklahoma City Thunder in 2008.31 In the NHL, two teams were moved from Canada to the US during the mid-1990s: the Quebec Nordiques became the Colorado Avalanche in 1995, and the Winnipeg Jets became the Phoenix Coyotes in 1996.3233 In 2005, one of Canada's two Major League Baseball teams, the Montreal Expos, relocated to become the Washington Nationals.34 The failure of the Vancouver franchise was part of the reason the NBA changed the expansion drafting rules following the Charlotte Bobcats' entry in 2005. The Bobcats were allowed to pick fourth in their first draft, and were later not restricted from first picks.35
In 2011, the ownership group of the Canucks, now owned by Francesco Aquilini, announced they were considering purchasing the Hornets. In December 2010, the Hornets were bought by the league, and there was potential for relocation due to the club's financial difficulties. However, a Hornets move was effectively taken off the table in 2012 when Tom Benson, a New Orleans native who already owned the NFL's New Orleans Saints, purchased the team.36 The city of Vancouver also attempted to purchase the Sacramento Kings from the Maloof family, but to no avail. In a major change from 2001—when one unnamed former NBA executive stated that a franchise would not return to Vancouver in his lifetime—Stern revealed in February 2011 that Vancouver was being considered along with Pittsburgh, Tampa and Kansas City. Reasons for considering Vancouver are the strengthening of the Canadian dollar, which has been roughly at par with the U.S. dollar since early 2010; the influx of international players who would be more willing to play in Canada; sell-outs for pre-season exhibition games at Rogers Arena (the new name of GM Place); Vancouver having a state-of-the-art venue; and an increased realization among NBA executives that the Vancouver failure was not predominantly because of lack of interest for basketball in Vancouver.37 The city has also been through a resurrection in professional sports, with the creation of the Vancouver Giants in junior hockey, the 2010 Winter Olympics, and Vancouver Whitecaps FC joining Major League Soccer. However, the location of the city also allows for more varied sports experiences, such as skiing, hunting, fishing and golf, which could partially limit the interest for spectator sports.6
- "Memphis Sounds Franchise Index". Sports Reference. Retrieved 22 May 2011.
- "The NBA Settles North of the Border". Memphis Grizzlies. Archived from the original on 16 September 2000. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- Lawrence, Mitch (12 January 2003). "'New' Charlotte gets fast break". Daily News. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "Memphis Grizzles Franchise Index". Sports Reference. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "McCaw Agrees to Purchase Griffiths' Shares in Orca Bay Sports & Entertainment". Orca Bay Sports & Entertainment. 12 November 1996. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- Beamish, Mike (19 February 2011). "NBA dreams rekindled, 10 years after Grizzlies’ demise". Vancouver Sun. Archived from the original on 7 July 2011. Retrieved 20 May 2011.
- Daniels, Craig (20 October 1999). "Grizzlies sale stinks for 52 million reasons". Toronto Sun. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "Grizzlies May Be Headed to St. Louis After Sale to Laurie". Los Angeles Times. 24 September 1999. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "St. Louis welcomes possibility of NBA team". CBS SportsLine. Associated Press. 23 September 1999. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "Vancouver Grizzlies back up for sale". Canadian Online Explorer. 21 January 2001. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- Shapiro, Mark (25 January 2001). "Chicagoan Buys Grizzlies, Says They'll Stay In Vancouver". Chicago Tribune. p. 2.
- Morris, Jim (22 March 2001). "Grizzlies a financial failure". CBC Sports. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- Rovell, Darren (8 February 2005). "NHL's future buoyed by die-hard fanbase". ESPN. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "1998-99 Vancouver Grizzlies Schedule and Results". Sports Reference. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "1999-00 Vancouver Grizzlies Schedule and Results". Sports Reference. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- Shaikin, Bill (1 March 2001). "Owner of Grizzlies Tours Las Vegas". Los Angeles Times. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "City Charms NBA's Grizzlies". Los Angeles Times. February 2001. Retrieved 23 May 2011.
- "Stakes Raised In Grizzlies Bidding War". WLKY. March 2001. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "NBA Approves Grizzlies' Move". Los Angeles Times. Associated Press. 4 July 2001. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "NBA Approves Grizzlies' Move". NBA.com. 3 July 2001.
- Shaikin, Bill (13 February 2001). "Anaheim Interested in Landing Grizzlies". Los Angeles Times. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "Buffalo joins cities trying to lure Grizzlies out of Vancouver". Canadian Television Network. 21 February 2001. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- Shaikin, Bill (24 March 2001). "Anaheim, Pond Still Not Ready to Concede Defeat". Los Angeles Times. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- Stahmer, Albrecht (9 November 2010). "Can Louisville Support an NBA Team?". Strait Pinkie. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "Memphis Grizzlies? It's looking that way". Deseret News. Associated Press. 26 March 2001. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "2000-01 Vancouver Grizzlies Schedule and Results". Sports Reference. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- Baird, Woody (4 July 2001). "NBA officially OKs team transfer to Memphis". Deseret News. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "NBA Attendance Report – 2001". ESPN. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "NBA Attendance Report – 2011". ESPN. Retrieved 22 May 2011.
- Green, Ron (2 November 2008). "Shinn: I messed up in Charlotte". Charlotte Observer. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- Pian Chan, Sharon (2 July 2002). "Sonics, city reach settlement". Seattle Times. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "Colorado Avalanche Franchise Index". Sports Reference. Retrieved 21 May 2011.
- "Phoenix Coyotes Franchise Index". Sports Reference. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- Myles, Stephanie (30 September 2004). "31,395 say goodbye". Montreal Gazette. p. C1.
- Lawrence, Mitch (12 January 2003). "'New' Charlotte gets fast break". Daily News. Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 28 August 2011.
- "NBA Sale of New Orleans Hornets to Tom Benson Is Finalized" (Press release). New Orleans Hornets. June 15, 2012. Retrieved July 8, 2012.
- Tsumura, Howard (16 February 2011). "Perfect storm turns in favour of Vancouver NBA team". The Province. Archived from the original on 17 July 2011. Retrieved 20 May 2011. Note also that the NBA executive who stated that the league would not return to Vancouver in his lifetime was still alive at the time of this story.